Guy Raz asked why Merrill bet on cottage cheese when sales of it were falling. He says the product already matched every big food trend and only needed reframing. This is how one of his investors pitched it.
…aging out, primarily private label driven, not relevant to today's consumer. Why we loved it was we looked at the megatrends at the time. We were like, and still today, but we're like, okay, what are the megatrends that are resonating in a big way right now? Okay, well, high protein resonating.
Yes. Low sugar. Yes,
the macro story resonating. Gut health resonating. Clean label resonating. Mission-led resonating. Founder-led resonating. Okay, well, guess what? We check all these boxes. And I remember when we were doing an earlier round of fundraising, one of the groups that invested presented it to their investment committee in that way and didn't even mention the words cottage cheese. They said, hey, we're thinking about investing in this really exciting company. It's a high-protein, clean-label, low-sugar, nutrient-dense real food. And they go, oh, wow, that sounds really interesting. What is it? And they go, it's something called cottage cheese. And they were like, like, mind-blown, right? So, like, so that was how we thought about it. We were like, we can, we can reframe this and in a way that will resonate because it's already checking all the megatrend boxes. It's just not being presented in the right way.
So you now have a lot of experience under your belt in marketing in the beverage space. First of all, where do you start? Like, you know, you want to make a different recipe of cottage cheese. I guess you could probably make it in a home kitchen, but what did you start to experiment and play around…
Yeah, so I did make kitchen samples. I would go to the market. I would buy a lot of the competition and I started to actually create my own version of cottage cheese. I would squeeze it several different private label, different national brands. I was just like exploring to see what was out there.…
But how do you come up with a recipe? I mean, you mentioned that you're buying off the shelf cottage cheese and squeezing out the water. So I bet you're putting it like cheesecloth or something just to see if you get a texture right. That's right. But when it comes to you actually making it or…