De Moura was asked why he is so protective of the core of Lean, the proof assistant he created, and won't merge whatever the community submits. He is passing on a colleague's line to explain it: half-finished features that look like they work are the danger in software other people rely on to verify proofs.
…This is an extension we implemented on top of Ling. I was really surprised. It was for software verification. They have a language that's much easier for people to verify software, especially if it's imperative software. Yeah, I was really blown. Yeah, they blew me away, I mean, with the demo.
…they could just make a mess of it. So they could do some operations and it's no longer vectorized and it's really slow. And perhaps in Lean, they could do something that actually affects the integrity of what they're doing. Is that part of it? So you want to put a little bit more control in?
Yeah, there is that. I mean, there's also people adding something that's half-baked. A lot of people like to have fun implementing software. Software is only, I like to see, actually, one of my academic brothers, he says, software is only fun if the software doesn't have to work. If it has to work, the fun disappears very quickly. And first issue, bugs, like you mentioned, people introducing bugs. Second issue, someone submits a feature that's not fully implemented. There are many holes. It looks like it works, but it doesn't. That's the thing. People may lock the design. They add a feature. It's complete. It's correct. But put constraints on how we can optimize the system. And now we have this feature. It may become…
So you're a depth-first search kind of guy. And when you build something successful that involves lots of other people, you have to become more like breadth-first search. And because there are so many things that are coming in every single day. And I remember there was a bit in Kevin's book where…
Yes. Oh, yes. Yeah. I forgot about this story of the kicking. Yeah, because at the point, at that point, wow, I really dislike people that keep throwing ideas. I mean, they don't even. They're having fun. I mean, it's different. I mean, for me, I was trying to build something that works. Some…
Yeah, it must be even worse now with Generative AI. I mean, so what you're pointing to there, it's called Brandellini's Law, which is that it takes exponentially more work to debunk bullshit than create it.