“Researchers are not the bottleneck, right? … Even two years ago in 2024, when I was chief research officer at OpenAI, the actual limiting factor was not the number of researchers we could hire. It was the amount of GPUs that we had on hand.”
sputnikintelligence.com
McGrew is pushing back on the 'hard takeoff' argument that automating AI researchers sets off runaway self-improvement. From his time running research at OpenAI, he says compute, not people, was the constraint.
…common perception and or there's a common argument, and I've been hearing it since like 2018, which says that if you can just automate the work of the researcher, that you're going to be able to unleash a runaway acceleration, runaway self-improvement loop, and we're going to have a singularity.
This is a hard takeoff.
…Now you have a 2X improvement. So now you're going 2X faster. And then you automate 90% of a researcher's time. You're going 10X faster. 99% automated, you're going 100x faster. And so by automating more and more of this job, you know, and eliminating this labor of the researcher, you're able to just, you know, zoom up and have runaway acceleration. But this is straightforwardly wrong because researchers are not the bottleneck, right? Like the amount of time it takes in order for you to discover something is not primarily bounded by the number of researchers you have. Fundamentally, those researchers are running experiments. And so, you know, if you actually think about the, you know, even today, right? Even two years ago in 2024, when I was chief research officer at OpenAI, like the actual limiting factor was not the number…
I feel like a lot of AI-driven research is basically stacking S-curves of different types or AI development, I should say, in general. That also translates into other domains, though. There's robotics, there's biology, there's a few other places where the physical world is really the primary…
Yeah. Before we talk about market structure, I think like, let's, let's think about what the actual, maybe the economic structure of this is. You know, the labs, if we think about what the labs are doing, they're really producing cheap intelligence. So what are the complements to intelligence? If…
Did you consider doing other working in other domains before you decide to go work on manufacturing and robotics?