MO Margaret O'Mara On GeekWire

“To overemphasize the novelty or the impossibility of containing it becomes a very convenient excuse. Not to regulate it, right? Oh, it's moving too fast. We can't regulate it.”

GeekWire · October 2026

“To overemphasize the novelty or the impossibility of containing it becomes a very convenient excuse. Not to regulate it, right? Oh, it's moving too fast. We can't regulate it.” — Margaret O'Mara, GeekWire

Context

O'Mara, a historian, was answering an audience question about AI regulation at a live GeekWire event. She grants that AI is broader than earlier technologies, then compares the moment to the first Gilded Age, when fast-growing new industries overwhelmed a small government until it built ways to regulate them. Her conclusion is that a lot being new doesn't mean nothing can be done.

Transcript

GeekWire Around 55:29 into the episode
John Cook

…to the graveyard and getting back to work. So I have this question I'm going to tack onto that, which is, why can't the tech giants create their own AI risk stop buttons instead of asking for it? This audience member asks. Is it just a PR game? I don't know if any of you know the answer to that.

Todd Bishop

…Now, whether they work or not, I guess that's the key question. And we've seen examples here of OpenAI doing some experiments, obviously, with the attack on Hugging Face. And so I think these systems can get a bit out of control and go rogue whether they kill us all. I'm not quite there yet.

Margaret O'Mara

Yeah. AI, in a way, is a boundary breaking, hard to compare to earlier technological transitions because of the scope of the technology. And AI is like a category, like saying the Pacific Ocean. Like there are many, many things that are encompassed in that definition of AI. It isn't just LLMs or chatbots, it's a whole bunch of other things. However, I think to overemphasize the novelty or the impossibility of containing it becomes a very convenient excuse. Not to regulate it, right? Oh, it's moving too fast. We can't regulate it. And I spend a lot of time, unsurprisingly, thinking about the Gilded Age, the first one, back, Carnegie, Rockefeller, et cetera, et cetera, where there was a similar, you know, real imbalance between these very fast-growing, technologically driven new industries that were totally upending job markets and economies, consumer markets, and kind of overwhelming the capacity of what was then a very…

David Hyde

One thing I observe in the debate for the most part is that most of the people, most of the time, are talking their book. And so that makes it very hard to really read what's actually going on. So Jensen Wong is out there saying, full speed ahead, there's no problems. Now, I'm sure that Jensen is a…

John Cook

disentangle his obvious business interest in holding that position from what he really thinks. So that's a problem kind of across the board. We're in the unfortunate moment of having this issue arise at a time where we essentially don't have any national political leadership that's able to deal…

David Hyde

Let me ask you a question from the audience. And I think this is a kind of captures some of the tech skepticism I think that some people feel. This is a question about taxes, right? Corporate taxes have been slashed at the federal level. We've all heard stories, you know, Microsoft and Amazon…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from GeekWire