GD Gordana Dodig-Crnkovic On Giants Shoulder

“Our obsession by measurement is really dominating science today. And I think we must go back to the meaning, not only the quantity, because quantity can be irrelevant, totally irrelevant. … You can measure whatever about the book. You will never know what this book means actually without focusing on that aspect.”

Giants Shoulder · October 2026

“Our obsession by measurement is really dominating science today. And I think we must go back to the meaning, not only the quantity, because quantity can be irrelevant, totally irrelevant. … You can measure whatever about the book. You will never know what this book means actually without focusing on that aspect.” — Gordana Dodig-Crnkovic, Giants Shoulder

Context

The interviewer asks whether the "information agents" in her account of nature can be physically measured. She gives the example of people who once compared books by counting their words.

Transcript

Giants Shoulder Around 33:49 into the episode
Gordana Dodig-Crnkovic

…was Sleepcevich and other people talking about how important it is that those agents, those things that are evolving, they do not evolve randomly. They have their own goals. They want to survive and they choose the way they behave. So it changes a lot how we see evolution as well. And we are also.

Speaker 3

…Can we measure how much information an agent contains? You know, like, are we going to hit the limits of our physical instrumentation with studying these informational agents? Do they even carry physical units in the same way that we think of other things carrying physical units and measurements?

Gordana Dodig-Crnkovic

There are two answers to your question. First is that, as I told you, there is this informational physics that rephrases the whole of physics, basic physics, in terms of information. So that's one thing. And the other thing is our obsession by measurement is really dominating science today. And I think we must go back to the meaning, not only the quantity, because quantity can be irrelevant, totally irrelevant. I remember at some point people were counting the number of words in books, concordances. They would compare books according to number of words or how many words certain words appear in a book. You can measure whatever about the book. You will never know what this book means actually without focusing on that aspect. So I think when we talk about intelligence, there is really a good reason to…

Speaker 3

Let's take concretely an example from Michael Levin. You've brought up his work a bunch of times, and he's just incredible. I've spoken to him twice now, and his work is just awesome. If we look at his Xenobots research, people really interpret that experiment in two ways. There's two sort of polar…

Gordana Dodig-Crnkovic

Yeah, I think the idea of the framework I'm developing is to try to say there are so many different levels of abstraction and different levels of description of a system. So, you can describe a human as a bag of chemicals. When I worked in the safety field, the human was modeled as a bag of water…

Speaker 3

trachea cells right the anthro bots or the

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Giants Shoulder