MT Michael Tomasello On Machine Learning Street Talk

“Lying only works because we're cooperative. Chimpanzees don't lie to one another because it would never occur to them that you would tell the truth if it didn't benefit. The reason lying works is that we're all gullible. We all expect everybody to be cooperative unless they have some ulterior motive. If I tell you it's raining outside, it would never occur to you that I'm lying about that.”

Machine Learning Street Talk · AI Research & Frontier Labs · November 2026

“Lying only works because we're cooperative. Chimpanzees don't lie to one another because it would never occur to them that you would tell the truth if it didn't benefit. The reason lying works is that we're all gullible. We all expect everybody to be cooperative unless they have some ulterior motive. If I tell you it's raining outside, it would never occur to you that I'm lying about that.” — Michael Tomasello, Machine Learning Street Talk

Context

Asked about the downsides of humans' capacity for shared agency and collective fictions, Michael Tomasello explains why deception works at all: it exploits a default expectation of cooperation that other apes don't have.

Transcript

Machine Learning Street Talk Around 52:02 into the episode
Michael Tomasello

Before I get to the bad thing, I just want to, when you say this virtualization, there's another element to it. Have you read Harari's book on homo sapiens, on sapiens? Oh,

Tim Scarfe

yeah, many years ago. Yes.

Michael Tomasello

Yes. So what he wants to point about in the virtualization is he says we live in an imaginative world where he's talking about things like dollars or pounds, presidents, prime ministers. Those are all things that only exist because we agree they exist. And if all of a sudden, you know, World War II happens, or I went to East Germany and East German marks were money. And then one day they weren't money anymore. They were pieces of paper. So this virtualization in culture comes from us creating what John Searle, the philosopher, calls status functions. That is, we make a person into a president, we make a piece of paper into money. And the most powerful forces on the world, Harari argues, is like corporations. You know, what is the Apple Corporation and what is Meta? These are what he calls fictions. They're made up. Corporations are fictional individuals that are legally individuals, but obviously not in a direct sense. So this virtualization is one of the things that culture does best and most powerfully is it creates new entities. Searle is quite strong on this. It is a fact that unfortunate fact that Donald Trump is president of the United States, right? That's a fact…

Tim Scarfe

And to what extent are these collective agencies a convergent or natural phenomenon? A lot of people talk about the market as if it is a sort of super organism.

Michael Tomasello

Yeah, I'm not a big fan of talking about inanimate things as agents. I mean, you could talk about capital as, you know, capital tends to flow toward this or that, but I would say it's the capitalists who make the decisions about where it flows and stuff. And there are these sociological level…

Tim Scarfe

Yeah, I think about this a lot because you were saying that in the market, it's supervenient on. It's like a super organism, supervenient on rational, intentional agents. And I mean, personally, my intuition is the best lens of analysis is to think of this thing as being an agent rather than a…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Machine Learning Street Talk