Connect your Claude, Codex or OpenClaw for full transcripts on millions of podcasts. Two week free trial, cancel anytime.

Start free trial →
DP David Pizarro Professor of psychology at Cornell University who studies how people make moral judgments and the role emotions, especially disgust, play in moral and political...

“The belief that philosophy is a kind of mathematics is damaging to the goals of philosophy that most people would endorse.”

Very Bad Wizards · Art & Philosophy · November 2026

“The belief that philosophy is a kind of mathematics is damaging to the goals of philosophy that most people would endorse.” — David Pizarro, Very Bad Wizards

Context

Tamler Sommers had asked whether a dialogue is better than a journal article for conveying philosophical ideas. Pizarro notes that the philosophy they're both drawn to is best communicated through fiction and art, and argues against treating the field as a kind of math.

Transcript

Very Bad Wizards Around 44:28 into the episode
David Pizarro

Yeah. And it just, it feels as if that is a shadow of the dialogues, which are the shadow of the experience. Exactly.

Tamler Sommers

…even be a shadow that's too far to be useful. I think one thing the dialogue is supposed to do is just get you close enough to the idea that it invites you all the way in. But it might be that the way the journal article, there's a kind of deadening effect to them that you're too far from the form.

David Pizarro

Yeah.

Tamler Sommers

I don't know. That's an interesting question. I don't even know where I stand on that.

David Pizarro

Yeah, I don't either. But it is interesting to me that the philosophy that we've been drawn to so often is of the kind that we, for instance, think is communicated best in artistic fictions. Because I do think, as much as I'm a whore for a reason, the belief that philosophy is a kind of mathematics…

Tamler Sommers

Yeah. Yeah. There is an analytic philosophy, especially in England and America, like it has modeled itself after math and science. And that might just be like not the right conception. And, you know, there are some philosophers like Bernard Williams or late Wittgenstein that kind of recognized…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Very Bad Wizards