PC Pamela Colloff Pamela Colloff Reporter at ProPublica.

“The courts look at precedent. They look backward. They feel that jury verdicts are sacrosanct. And with some good reason, juries saw live testimony and all sorts of things that we can't see reading a dry transcript. But it comes at such a cost because of this belief in finality and that there has to be an end to the proceedings and that finality sort of trumps accuracy.”

The Daily Stoic · Ideas & Essays · November 2026

“The courts look at precedent. They look backward. They feel that jury verdicts are sacrosanct. And with some good reason, juries saw live testimony and all sorts of things that we can't see reading a dry transcript. But it comes at such a cost because of this belief in finality and that there has to be an end to the proceedings and that finality sort of trumps accuracy.” — Pamela Colloff, The Daily Stoic

Context

Ryan Holiday noted that legal procedures can feel onerous but guard against colossal mistakes. Pamela Colloff explains why courts aren't built to recognise that a conviction was wrong once it's on the books.

Transcript

The Daily Stoic Around 16:03 into the episode
Pamela Colloff

…they haven't hammered out a deal. So Hard can say that. And then on the back end, he's rewarded with freedom or other benefits. But jurors don't understand any of that. You know, they're sort of coming into this fresh, and yet they're the ones that have to make the decision about everything.

Ryan Holiday

And the different sort of precedents and systems that we've set up that can feel onerous and can feel like they get in the way of justice. They also get in the way of making these colossal, tragic mistakes, like getting it so terribly, terribly wrong.

Pamela Colloff

Yes. And then we have a conviction on the books that if enough lawyers or reporters dig into it in certain cases, it turns out to be wrong. And then the system just is not built for recognizing that and not built for acting upon that. The courts look at precedent. They look backward. They feel that jury verdicts are sacrosanct. And with some good reason, juries saw live testimony and all sorts of things that we can't see reading a dry transcript. But it comes at such a cost because of this belief in finality and that there has to be an end to the proceedings and that finality sort of trumps accuracy.

Ryan Holiday

Right.

Pamela Colloff

Something else we've seen is that so many things come to light later that can't at the time of the trial. I was just writing about some other cases in Florida on death row with defendants on death row. And it's not until they're given a death warrant often by the governor, they may have been…

Ryan Holiday

Well, I wanted to ask you about that because it's really hard to admit you're wrong, right? And I'm writing right now about the Gulf of Tonkin. First off, it's difficult to make sense of this thing that happened. And I have all the facts in chronological order. Right. But one of the things that…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from The Daily Stoic