RR Ray Redacted On Smashing Security

“The problem is 99% of the people that are using these agents are not doing that. They're defaulting to give it full access to absolutely everything. And by the way, in the case of Muse, this is Facebook. So you do have to ask yourself: would you give Facebook copies of the keys to your house and your car and your children's social security numbers, right? Because millions of people are doing that.”

Smashing Security · Software Engineering & Infra · November 2026

“The problem is 99% of the people that are using these agents are not doing that. They're defaulting to give it full access to absolutely everything. And by the way, in the case of Muse, this is Facebook. So you do have to ask yourself: would you give Facebook copies of the keys to your house and your car and your children's social security numbers, right? Because millions of people are doing that.” — Ray Redacted, Smashing Security

Context

Graham asked whether Ray lets an AI agent act on his computer. Ray runs his in a read-only container, then points out that most people hand agents full access, including Meta's Muse, which is in the news this week for privacy problems.

Transcript

Smashing Security Around 36:03 into the episode
Ray Redacted

…Ermi's agent or Grokbot or Claude or DOT, you may give it full access to your computer, right? Here's a full access to my entire hard drive, et cetera. And suddenly the stakes change. And the next thing you know, your cryptocurrency wallet is just as empty as mine. But mine was stolen by the face.

Graham Cluley

…that is when it gets really scary, though, isn't it? Is when it's Agentic AI, which is going to go wrong rather than the chat bot going wrong and telling you something daft. You don't have to tell me if you're not comfortable doing so, Ray, but do you let an AI actually do things on your computer?

Ray Redacted

100%. Absolutely. Oh, my goodness, Ray. There are ways you can use Agentic AI and be safe. Like, for example, I run Ermes in a container. I use Docker, right? It doesn't have access to read-write activities. If you want to give it financial accounts, there are ways you can do read-only so that it can't write and it doesn't have any credentials, et cetera. But here's the problem, Graham. The problem is 99% of the people that are using these agents are not doing that. They're defaulting to give it full access to absolutely everything. And by the way, in the case of Muse, this is Facebook. So you do have to ask yourself: would you give Facebook copies of the keys to your house and your car and your children's social security numbers, right? Because millions of people are doing that.

Graham Cluley

They've already got that. So why do they need it again? But so, yes,

Ray Redacted

with Agentic, it changes the stakes, so to speak. But in theory, running local models and giving that Agentic ability, if it's properly segmented, if it's got separate VLANs, et cetera, it can be the safest way to do this because you're not transmitting that to the cloud. Microsoft's put a little…

Graham Cluley

So, Ray, come New Year's Eve, right? You're there with your little sherry. You've got your little party hat on. You're waiting for the fireworks and everything. Do you think we should be unplugging our AI agents before midnight? It could be any time, though, couldn't it? It wouldn't necessarily be…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Smashing Security