JR John Romero On The Stack Overflow Podcast

“I don't think so because the idea is the most important thing that you got. And an agent can execute that idea. But if you don't have the idea, it's not going to have the idea at all, right?”

The Stack Overflow Podcast · Hands-On Engineering Podcasts · November 2026

“I don't think so because the idea is the most important thing that you got. And an agent can execute that idea. But if you don't have the idea, it's not going to have the idea at all, right?” — John Romero, The Stack Overflow Podcast

Context

Asked whether developers lose something by using coding agents instead of hand-writing everything the way the Doom and Quake team did, Romero says the invention still has to come from the person.

Transcript

The Stack Overflow Podcast Around 30:22 into the episode
John Romero

This is exactly how you want to talk to it. And so they're like, all right, this is great. And we get everybody to agree on this. That'll be really nice.

Ryan Donovan

…today is like very like. Innovative stuff that hadn't been done, stuff you had to figure out on the fly. In today's sort of programming environment, almost everybody's using coding agents. Yeah. Do you think there's going to be something lost by using coding agents by not doing everything by hand?

John Romero

I don't think so because the idea is the most important thing that you got. And an agent can execute that idea. But if you don't have the idea, it's not going to have the idea at all, right? That's what's really important. Like as an example, in Quake, it's a client-server model. You have characters moving through the world. You have NPC monsters. They need to know where to go. They need to collide with the walls to know that they're hitting a wall to go this way, right? So all of these collision checks, they're full 3D checks, which is really expensive normally. And so to come up…

Ryan Donovan

Doing a bunch of math, right? You're

John Romero

doing a bunch of math, right? So if we can reduce this check to a single point check, if this point collides with anything, then you've hit a wall. If not, you're fine. If we make it one check, then success. And that's what we did. And the way that we take a whole rectangle and make it a point is…

Ryan Donovan

Wow.

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from The Stack Overflow Podcast