Uncomfortable Conversations with Josh Szeps · In-Depth Interviews · November 2026
Describing life before modern medicine, when bloodletting was the standard cure for almost anything, Chelsea Follett, author of The Grim Olden Days, uses Washington's death as her example.
…dancing around maples, eating food fresh from the farm, breathing clean air, treating their farm animals kindly, warm, loving communities again. Like this is the view that most people have of the world before industrialization. There's, and I think there's just so much misunderstanding around this.
…and we can come back to the big lofty philosophical stuff afterwards, because I want you to be able to articulate what your book actually talks about. Give us a paint a picture, paint a picture, pick a year, give me the year, or give me the decade, give me the place, tell me what life was like.
The central concept of this book is that no matter where you were in the world and whether you were living in antiquity, again, even the days of the Roman Empire, or just prior to industrialization, if you were an average person working as a subsistence farmer, your life was very similar in a lot of ways. Here is what your life would be like. As a subsistence farmer, you would begin toiling in the fields from the moment you could walk. You would not have a play-filled, enriched childhood. Chances were high that you would not be literate. You would not know how to read. If you were married, it might be out of economic necessity. Perhaps you would never leave your small village. And so your partner choices would be extremely limited. Maybe the only people available to marry would be with a huge age gap to you. Maybe your first cousins over a few generations compounding that increases the likelihood of birth defects. Maybe it would be just someone with a personality that's completely incompatible with yours or who you're not attracted to, that you…
the blood, like it's not like he was going to a Red Cross clinic and they were putting in a sanitized needle and putting it into a plastic blood bag. You mean they would just cut the person and let them bleed into a dish.
Yes, they would cut you or they would apply leeches or both and they would bleed you into a dish. Again, this was standard for centuries upon centuries. It would actually be irresponsible. Probably most of the people of the past would think of it to go without this treatment. And there were no…
and there are no antibiotics.