Ask Noah Show · Hands-On Engineering Podcasts · November 2026
A listener asked whether running VLANs through unmanaged switches is safe. Noah describes the habit he formed after locking himself out of his router with a bad VLAN tag.
…stuff in and knows enough to start configuring, I mean, there may have been some value to that back when a managed switch was three grand from Cisco, but today you can buy a TP link for 29 bucks off the jungle store and it'll show up in two days. I'm not sure what we're really solving there.
…that you buy that has a managed, like a management VLAN will be on that VLAN. And so you probably should just move it off just out of, you know, don't be on the managed VLAN because that's where all those things to include PFSense. PFSense has that default admin VLAN that it wants to be on.
One of the things that I've done in PFSense is, so typically you'll have more than one port. And I, once I start doing VLANs, this lesson comes written in blood. So I have had one too many times where I have some problem on the switch or some problem tagging or whatever. And then I get myself into a real pickle because now how do I even get into the router to start troubleshooting? Because I can't get into the router because it's all tagged. And then there's this complication, right? So what I have become in the habit of doing is I'll take PFSense and I will take the one of the unused ports and I will leave that at the default 192.168.1.whatever, no tagging whatsoever. And that's just kind of my backup, in case a glass break, in case of an emergency, break glass port. And I can plug in and just get a normal IP address on a regular untagged, very uncomplicated thing, at least log into the router. And then I can go back and, oops, I fat-fingered that tag. I didn't get that right. I turned the port off altogether. Whatever the problem may be, I can go back and figure it out. But I live to fight another day.
Well, we want you to continue living to fight many more days to come.
Right, exactly. I think so. All right. Our third email comes in from Joe. Joe writes in and says, hi, Noah and Steve. I'm running multiple Proxmox nodes for my home lab, and I just upgraded to Proxmox 9. I was attempting to use the Proxmox. Data center manager to migrate an LXC from one node to…
I don't. I poked at the old internet there and found that it is normal that some configuration changes happen via Proxmox in the LXC star.conf directory when it migrates around. Given my lack of domain and lack of additional detail about what is actually changing, I couldn't go much further than…