MO Matt O'Dowd Is an astrophysicist and associate professor at Lehman College, City University of New York, with a research background in astronomy and astrophysics from the U...

“If you could collect all the Hawking radiation that evaporated out of a black hole over trillions of years, every little bit, and somehow piece it together, the worst jigsaw puzzle in the universe, you should be able to reconstruct the chair.”

StarTalk Radio · Ideas & Essays · November 2026

“If you could collect all the Hawking radiation that evaporated out of a black hole over trillions of years, every little bit, and somehow piece it together, the worst jigsaw puzzle in the universe, you should be able to reconstruct the chair.” — Matt O'Dowd, StarTalk Radio

Context

A listener asked whether anything that falls into a black hole is lost forever. O'Dowd explained that many physicists now think Hawking radiation carries out not just energy but information, using a co-host's example of a chair thrown into a black hole.

Transcript

StarTalk Radio Around 07:29 into the episode
Neil deGrasse Tyson

So they get remembered. They get remembered. Right, yeah.

Chuck Nice

So it's almost like whatever it is, although it's not a chair that went in. All of the things, the blueprint information on that tiny, tiny level, when it comes out, that is still available.

Matt O'Dowd

Yeah, if you could go to the, you know, if you could collect all the Hawking radiation that evaporated out of a black hole over trillions of years, every little bit, and somehow piece it together, the worst jigsaw puzzle in the universe, you should be able to reconstruct the chair.

Chuck Nice

And that's what you guys mean when you say information. You're talking about all the stuff that we actually are on that. The inventory, the part of the inventory on the quantum, all the way down to that part. Yeah, the information that you would need,

Matt O'Dowd

if you wanted to rewind the universe and find out what happened previously, if you had all the information, then in principle, you could run the clock backwards and figure out what fell into the black hole in the first place.

Neil deGrasse Tyson

And just to clarify a point you're making, you're saying it came out of the black hole, but in fact, it came out of the energy field in the vicinity of the black hole, which counts as coming out of the black hole. Is that right?

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from StarTalk Radio