HG Harjot Gill On The Pragmatic Engineer

“The human code review is dead, but the human review is not dead. Some review still has to happen.”

The Pragmatic Engineer · Hands-On Engineering Podcasts · November 2026

“The human code review is dead, but the human review is not dead. Some review still has to happen.” — Harjot Gill, The Pragmatic Engineer

Context

Gergely Orosz asked whether code review is dead, saying on many teams it has become theater with LGTM comments and nobody reading the diffs. Harjot agrees line-by-line review is over, but says humans still have to review something higher up.

Transcript

The Pragmatic Engineer
Harjot Gill

…thing is that like the cost perspective, I think I will be also as a leader comfortable spending the money if I can see where it's adding the value. Like if it's in the Slack, so we have a Slack bot over there when Code Rabbit responds to all the data dog alerts. I clearly see it's adding value.

Gergely Orosz

…longer have comments. They no longer read it. And companies like Uber are now making changes to just make it so much easier for people to, you know, like see what a code review does because they also know people no longer spend less and less time reading it because there's just more of them, right?

Harjot Gill

You're right. I mean, the human code review is dead, but the human review is not dead. Some review still has to happen. If you look at the software development space, there used to be like an upstream kind of a guard, like when you were like planning the work because your engineering was an expensive resource. So when you were using the tools like Linear Jira, one of the reasons to do this agile and sprints was to make sure their developers are working on most important tasks.

Gergely Orosz

We don't like spend a bunch of time and effort building something that was throw away. Exactly.

Harjot Gill

So there was a lot of regulation upstream earlier. Now that floodgate has suddenly opened with AI. Now you can go from idea to code without going through planning. Like you have a support ticket coming in. People will just ask Devin to look at it or code have it slackwad or something, right? At the…

Gergely Orosz

And then when you say human review, just to be clear, human means software engineer, or can it also mean non-software engineer? I'm just curious if you still think the accountability needs to sit with people who kind of know the internals or can it be someone else? Can it be product manager or…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from The Pragmatic Engineer