ND Nima Dehghani On Brain Inspired

“If computation is that everything computes, then it's a useless word, and why are we even saying it? If I throw a rock and then say the rock computes its trajectory, does the solar system compute its future state? If that's computation, then everything that moves, everything that changes is computation.”

Brain Inspired · AI Research & Frontier Labs · November 2026

“If computation is that everything computes, then it's a useless word, and why are we even saying it? If I throw a rock and then say the rock computes its trajectory, does the solar system compute its future state? If that's computation, then everything that moves, everything that changes is computation.” — Nima Dehghani, Brain Inspired

Context

The host worried that neuroscientists say "the circuit computes" as a filler term that empties the word of meaning. Dehghani agrees, and says this is the problem his formal theory of physical computation is meant to fix.

Transcript

Brain Inspired Around 14:26 into the episode
Nima Dehghani

That's my concern. They go to this sort of like hand-waving sort of arguments. Right. But that is. And they become a true believer that it is or it isn't. Right.

Paul Middlebrooks

Right. So my concern is like when you say like the brain computes, the word computation just gets applied to whatever the brain is doing. You call it computation. And that kind of trivializes the notion of computation also. Exactly. You avoid that.

Nima Dehghani

I think that's a big issue, right? Like we don't want to open, you know, if computation is everything computes, then it's a useless word. And why are we even saying it? If I throw a rock and then say, well, you know, the paper is like, you know, the rock computes trajectory. Does the solar system, you know, know what, compute its future state? Like, I mean, if that's computation, then like, okay, so everything that moves, everything that changes is computation. So not every state changes computation. Not every information transfer is a computation. And that's actually the key point here because in that formalization, and you know, I don't want to throw out jargons here because, you know, I don't want to bore all the audience. And, you know, if they're more interested, they can go and read the papers. Yeah, yeah, yeah. And I try to bring different levels of description that, you know, people can. So

Paul Middlebrooks

I'll just, I'll tell people, like, you're making these videos that are kind of explainers of the concepts. And they're fantastic videos. Your papers are very dense. The videos are also very dense. Like, even though you're simplifying things, there's so many things that you've included that, you…

Nima Dehghani

You know, it's funny because I think that's true. Like my papers are very long in general. Like I don't, generally, I don't write short papers. I like very long papers because I want to really get into the details. So it's not that I cannot write short papers, but I think I don't like short papers.…

Paul Middlebrooks

And do you, well, before I ask you about category theory, because this is sort of category theory is a necessary ingredient to this. Actually, I'll go ahead and ask you about that. I mean, you used the word functor. Is category theory the without it? Could you do? Could you explain the computational

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Brain Inspired