GM Gary Marcus Gary Marcus Scientist, author and entrepreneur, known as a leading voice in AI. Six books including The Algebraic Mind, Rebooting AI, and Taming Silicon Valley; NYU Profess...

“I always think of what I call the trillion-pound baby fallacy, which comes from a tweet. A guy had a picture of his baby, and he says, my baby has doubled in weight in its first month of life, and I've taken the liberty of making some projections: by the time he goes to college, he'll be a trillion pounds. And of course, the point is that you can have exponential growth for a while, but usually it tails off.”

Big Technology · Tech Strategy & Big Tech · November 2026

“I always think of what I call the trillion-pound baby fallacy, which comes from a tweet. A guy had a picture of his baby, and he says, my baby has doubled in weight in its first month of life, and I've taken the liberty of making some projections: by the time he goes to college, he'll be a trillion pounds. And of course, the point is that you can have exponential growth for a while, but usually it tails off.” — Gary Marcus, Big Technology

Context

The host had laid out the bear case that Anthropic's IPO valuation rests on sustained growth and on an era of uncapped corporate AI spending. Marcus uses the joke to argue the revenue curve won't keep compounding. It is his core argument against the valuation.

Transcript

Big Technology Around 06:12 into the episode
Gary Marcus

Where were you when I needed you? I'm not

Alex Kantrowitz

a token maxing defender because the other side of it is. I mean, that would be the argument. When you gamify it, it's just like you're going to lead to people running loops, unending loops of token spending. People were running top 40 agents overnight

Gary Marcus

because they got paid more money because they were running more agents. And so all that stopped, right? And so, I mean, going back to the more serious point, the reason people think that this company is valued at $2 trillion or $1.5 trillion is partly because they saw graphs like the one Joseph Jacks had, which got, I don't know, millions of views on Twitter. Joseph Jacks had this plot. It has the weirdest y-axis I've ever seen. The numbers go up and then down and then up again. And it's like sort of trying to be logarithmic. Anyway, ignore the y-axis on this crazy graph. It plotted Anthropic making more revenue than Google or Alphabet by like 2028 or something like that. And just, you know, rapid, rapid rise in revenue. And what I said then was this depends on this fad of token maxing. This fad is not going to last. And so you have these projections. I always think of what I call the trillion-pound baby fallacy, which comes from a tweet that I saw on Twitter that absolutely left. A guy had a picture of his baby and then his baby like a month later. And it was kind of a joke. He says, you know, my baby has doubled in weight in its first month of life or something like that. And I've taken…

Alex Kantrowitz

Indeed, let's go to your post. You said quarter two growth was 147%. It was up 147% compared to Q1. But Q3 wound up being a mere 47% in growth compared to Q2. The decline of token maxing and the rise of good quality, if not quite top-tier competitors from China, began to take their toll. I just…

Gary Marcus

Yep. Yeah. No, I mean, it didn't die completely. It's just, That you got $900 billion of obligation. I mean, another way to put it is it would be a good business if the liabilities weren't so high. I mean, maybe that's sort of the story of all businesses that fail. But, you know, they are making a…

Alex Kantrowitz

Yep. All right. Diminishing returns, I think. We've talked about this on previous episodes. You bring it up again. Let me just set it up. You write the cost of making better AI and Anthropic's only real niche is models at the extreme top end, since they can readily be beat on price at the low end…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Big Technology