Startups For the Rest of Us · Bootstrapped & Indie SaaS · November 2026
Tracy had just listed the engagement tactics they tried on Circle, from points for posting to onboarding sequences. Rob compares it to a SaaS company treating churn symptoms instead of admitting it lacks product-market fit.
…it's always kind of unknown, right? So it became apparent, I think, within the first three to six months, maybe. I think it was after a few months, we were like, okay, we're noticing some hiccups, but like certainly after six months, what did we see? What were the signs that it wasn't working?
…as community managers too that brought on to Slack based on this era. But a lot of it was like, I needed to take a look at the actual platform and be like, you know what? We've done so much work here, but we're still hitting this like gigantic headwind. So what would it look like if we moved again?
Yep. Which is like, oh, gosh, we don't want to do this. It reminds me, though, of SaaS products that don't have product market fit. And they start using, so they have high churn and then they start using a bunch of tactics to reduce churn. They're like, well, let's move to annual only. So then churn will go down and let's make it harder to cancel or let's make, you know, whatever. There's a bunch of different things you can do to game it and to improve it. But if you do that, it actually masks the root problem and the root problem with a SaaS app. It's like, you don't have product market fit. And the root problem here, I really do believe is the platform. Like you're saying, yeah, maybe it's not. No, I think, I think that is the core. I think that's 90% of any of the issues is that for our users in our community, Slack is just so far superior to Circle.
Yeah. And, you know, it's something as when I was a startup founder and people said, you'll know you have product market fit because things become easy. But it's, it's like, it's, you don't know that you don't actually like really internalize that until it actually happens. And then you're like…
And so you did some interviews with people, right?
Yeah.