JD

Josh Dzieza

Things Josh Says on Podcasts

Where to Find Them

Josh Dzieza hosts The Vergecast . They have also been a guest on Decoder with Nilay Patel .

Recently: “How Utah locals fought Kevin O'Leary's AI data center” on Decoder with Nilay Patel (October 2026); “The internet really is a series of tubes” on The Vergecast (April 2024); “How AI really works, and how the smart home broke” on The Vergecast (June 2023); “Quibi is shutting down / Google faces antitrust charges / Foxconn’s LCD factory is Wisconsin isn’t real” on The Vergecast (October 2020); “Air Bud 6” on The Vergecast (May 2015).

What They Said

“It's just really different from any kind of other big development projects because not only are people acutely aware of the costs, but there's no pros. It's not like people are excited for jobs.” — Josh Dzieza, Decoder with Nilay Patel

Dzieza reported on a Utah community that fought a large AI data center project. The host contrasts it with an earlier factory project in Wisconsin that locals wanted to believe in. Here Dzieza explains why the backlash was immediate: residents didn't believe the jobs numbers and saw little upside.

Decoder with Nilay Patel · 2026-10-01 Permalink → Listen →
Decoder with Nilay Patel Around 11:20 into the episode
Josh Dzieza

…they like know broadly what's coming, some of which is exaggerated, some of which isn't, but like you don't need to get people up to speed that they realize, oh my God, this huge project is supposed to be, you know, they're saying it's nine gigawatts and it's coming to your metaphorical backyard.

Nilay Patel

…a data center. But the people there did not want that. It was the very opposite. All of the hopes and dreams were replaced by people's anger and fear about AI and maybe what they'd heard on social media. How did that play out in this story? Because that feels like a massive point of departure.

Josh Dzieza

…to hate. And so you have people who are upset for environmental reasons. You have people who are upset about the tax breaks, who have people who are upset about just kind of like surveillance spheres with AI. You have just kind of everything in there. And people start protesting right away and saying, you know, we don't want this is something that you hear all the time at these protests. It's just really different from any kind of other big development projects because not only are people acutely aware of the costs, but there's no pros. It's not like people are excited for jobs. And Utah is not, unlike Wisconsin, not a deindustrialized area. It's an agricultural community for the most part. Like people are not nostalgic for the golden age of manufacturing. And they don't believe any of the jobs numbers anyone tosses out with data centers, I think, rightly for the most part. And there's just not a lot of upside. You know, your county taxes might go down in 10 years. It's…

Nilay Patel

You talked to a lot of the protesters, the people who succeeded in having this project scale down pretty dramatically. Who are these characters? What are they like?

Josh Dzieza

There's a wide range of people. I got some, one of the records that I thought was really fascinating that I got came from kind of a state intelligence fusion center thing talking to the sheriff saying, you know, just heads up, it's in theory, a very combustible group of people who's going to be…

Speaker 2

Support for the show comes from CrowdStrike. AI is already fundamentally changing how companies

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

Collections They Appear In