“Because of the compute supply chain chokehold the United States and its allies have on China, we can deny China computing power, build a lead over them without being unduly accelerationist ourself. And then the phrase we used to use is spend that lead on safety.”
sputnikintelligence.com
Nathan Labenz asked the two former Biden White House advisors for the worldview behind their AI policy work. Buchanan lays out the strategy that gives the episode its title: the chip lead is meant to buy time for safety, not fuel a race.
…countries with other systems of government. Should they get an advantage in the technology relative to us? You know, those are neutral terms. What are your kind of more colorful terms that really motivate all of the actions that you tried to take in government in terms of the geopolitical outlook?
…in the book. And the main goal there is not to say we have to win because winning is good, but is to say we want to think about sequencing these actions so that we can produce outcomes that get the things that are clearly good for the world and avoid things that are clearly bad for the world.
I agree. I think we could be a little more hard-nosed about it. And the inspiration here is a speech that Kennedy gives in 1962 at Rice University. President Biden actually had this speech on the wall of his private study just off the Oval office and it resonated with him, I think, for a lot of reasons, probably not related to AI. It resonated with me because it, I think, is the best insight into the AI policy we were trying to build. In this speech, Kennedy goes and says, we're going to go to the moon and back within a decade. Everyone knows that part. Most people don't know the last part of the speech where Kennedy makes the case to the American people for why space matters. And he says something like, we don't know whether space will be good or ill for humanity, but only if we have preeminence can we help decide. The vowels of this nation demand that we must be first and therefore we shall be first. And you can sort of dial up the rah-rah America as much or as little as you'd want. But I do think in doing the geopolitical calculation that…
So, hey, we'll continue our interview in a moment after a word from our sponsors.
The cognitive
revolution is brought to you and powered by Tasklet. I've been running Tasklet agents for almost a year, and they've become a major part of how the show gets made. Before every recording, one agent researches the guest and sends me a suggested outline of questions, complete with links to all…