PB

Peter Bergen

Things Peter Says on Podcasts

Where to Find Them

Peter Bergen has been a guest on The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition (2 times) .

Recently: “Lawfare Daily: A Progress Report on the War on Terrorism with Peter Bergen” on The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition (October 2026); “Peter Bergen Reassessing Osama bin Laden” on The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition (August 2021).

What They Said

“JSOC is an industrial level killing machine, but do you want to apply it to every problem? The answer, of course, is no. And people in JSOC know that as much as anybody else.” — Peter Bergen, The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition

Bergen was asked which counterterrorism reforms since 9/11 worked and should be kept. He put Joint Special Operations Command at the top of the list, then added this caution. Later in the same answer he criticised treating drug cartels as terrorist organizations.

The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition · 2026-10-06 Permalink → Listen →
The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition Around 38:51 into the episode
Speaker 1

…story in Syria just recently is you're not going to use credit cards there, which I mean, it's something we take for granted, but it hadn't happened for a long time. So Syria is in the process of joining the kind of slightly somewhat functional Middle Eastern states, right? I mean, that's the hope.

Speaker 2

…reforms. And you mentioned the crystal earlier, the kind of, I'll say, how JSOC has really kind of blossomed as a counterterrorism machine over time. What would you look at and say this one worked really well and should be continued? This was keep this particular capability or approach.

Speaker 1

…Task, it was like a revelation because basically all the stuff that JSOC was doing, JSOC itself was not a well-known entity, but suddenly we had this other history. And then NSA has declassified the real-time regional gateway, which is NSA's ability to listen to a lot of calls. And obviously that's gone on and there's problems with too much surveillance and that can be a double-edged sword. And JSOC is an industrial level killing machine, but do you want to apply it to every problem? The answer, of course, is no. And people in JSOC know that as much as anybody else. What else worked? TSA worked, I think. It's annoying to go through TSA checkpoints, but in terms of keeping us safe, it's mostly done that. DHS, I think, is sort of a mixed bag because it's sort of like behamless. I think the National Counterterrorism Center, which is part of the Office of Director of National Intelligence, has actually worked pretty well. The Office of Director of National…

Speaker 2

I want to close by asking you a couple, I'll say, forward-leaning sort of questions. One is, of course, the war the United States is currently engaged in, which is Iran. And you discuss this a little bit in your book. This question of kind of what to do about Iran is a very difficult one. I…

Speaker 1

I think there are that, Dan. I mean, what would you want at the beginning of a war? You'd want a congressional authorization in favor. You'd want public buy-in. You'd want NATO allies. You want maybe a UN resolution in favor. You'd want a plan for the day after, and you'd want a strategy. And other…

Speaker 2

Last question for you. Let's imagine a bad future. There is another massive attack on the American homeland. It emanates from abroad. We could say Somalia or Mali, someplace where al-Qaeda-type groups are active that currently some have links to the Al-Corp de Corps or what remains of it. What…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“It's kind of childish to think that a fairly major nuclear-armed power is just going to do what we want them to do.” — Peter Bergen, The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition

Bergen was talking about Americans who served in Afghanistan and blame Pakistan for sheltering the Taliban leadership. His view is that Pakistan was always going to act in its own security interest, and that it hedged because it expected the United States to leave. He adds that on that last point Pakistan turned out to be right.

The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition · 2026-10-06 Permalink → Listen →
The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition Around 19:26 into the episode
Speaker 1

…table with them in earnest under the Trump term one in 2018, they drove a very hard bargain, a bargain that was a terrible one, which was no Afghan elected government officials at the table, pretending to separate from al-Qaeda, et cetera, et cetera, and all the things you know that they didn't do.

Speaker 2

…would have scratched their head even more in 2001. They're saying, right, you know, this guy who just murdered 3,000 Americans, you know, you're letting him go. But are there things you look back and you're like, okay, that was a mistake in hindsight, but I'm actually very sympathetic to it.

Speaker 1

Well, I mean, some of the mistakes are so big, you can't be, I mean, the Iraq War of Choice helped undercut. I think the Iraq War of Choice and the financial crisis in 2008 really kind of, there's a reason that Americans are very suspicious of their elites because they seem to have absolutely no idea what they're doing. And the Iraq war permanently hobbled Hillary Clinton's chances of becoming president. It greatly enabled President Barack Obama to become president, and the war on terror was quite useful for Trump as a, you know, the Muslim ban was a somewhat popular idea and for terrorism was top of mind in the first Trump term election because ISIS was at its height. So I will say that as I was writing this, you know, counterinsurgency, you were called down at a certain point in DC became a sort of religion. And I will include myself as somebody who was sort of converted. At first start, I knew very…

Speaker 2

I would strongly agree with your point about limited numbers of U.S. troops can do a lot. I think both recognizing that capacity, but also, as you said, understanding the limits is vital, right? You're not going to do regime change in Iraq in the sense of putting in a new government that's stable…

Speaker 1

Well, also, you know, I mean, some of this is so basic, it's amazing that we have to even say this, but like understanding the environment you're about to go into. I think it was Jeff Stein, who was an American journalist. I believe it was he, he'd often ask American politicians what's the…

Speaker 2

that is depressing. I want to drag you back to a conversation we had almost 25 years ago that you may not even remember, and perhaps I'm misremembering. But I will say for readers who don't know, Peter was, to my knowledge, the first outside person, non-government person, to warn about Al-Qaeda…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

Collections They Appear In