The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition · October 2026
Bergen was talking about Americans who served in Afghanistan and blame Pakistan for sheltering the Taliban leadership. His view is that Pakistan was always going to act in its own security interest, and that it hedged because it expected the United States to leave. He adds that on that last point Pakistan turned out to be right.
…table with them in earnest under the Trump term one in 2018, they drove a very hard bargain, a bargain that was a terrible one, which was no Afghan elected government officials at the table, pretending to separate from al-Qaeda, et cetera, et cetera, and all the things you know that they didn't do.
…would have scratched their head even more in 2001. They're saying, right, you know, this guy who just murdered 3,000 Americans, you know, you're letting him go. But are there things you look back and you're like, okay, that was a mistake in hindsight, but I'm actually very sympathetic to it.
Well, I mean, some of the mistakes are so big, you can't be, I mean, the Iraq War of Choice helped undercut. I think the Iraq War of Choice and the financial crisis in 2008 really kind of, there's a reason that Americans are very suspicious of their elites because they seem to have absolutely no idea what they're doing. And the Iraq war permanently hobbled Hillary Clinton's chances of becoming president. It greatly enabled President Barack Obama to become president, and the war on terror was quite useful for Trump as a, you know, the Muslim ban was a somewhat popular idea and for terrorism was top of mind in the first Trump term election because ISIS was at its height. So I will say that as I was writing this, you know, counterinsurgency, you were called down at a certain point in DC became a sort of religion. And I will include myself as somebody who was sort of converted. At first start, I knew very…
I would strongly agree with your point about limited numbers of U.S. troops can do a lot. I think both recognizing that capacity, but also, as you said, understanding the limits is vital, right? You're not going to do regime change in Iraq in the sense of putting in a new government that's stable…
Well, also, you know, I mean, some of this is so basic, it's amazing that we have to even say this, but like understanding the environment you're about to go into. I think it was Jeff Stein, who was an American journalist. I believe it was he, he'd often ask American politicians what's the…
that is depressing. I want to drag you back to a conversation we had almost 25 years ago that you may not even remember, and perhaps I'm misremembering. But I will say for readers who don't know, Peter was, to my knowledge, the first outside person, non-government person, to warn about Al-Qaeda…