Decoder with Nilay Patel · Tech Strategy & Big Tech · October 2026
Patel is the one being interviewed here, by Shumita Basu. He has just said the US essentially failed to regulate social media and privacy, and argues AI may go differently because public sentiment toward it is already negative.
…federal privacy law. And we are now contending with the effects of that, right? All over the place, people feel their privacy is being violated. They think that we know that the TVs are listening and watching to everything you consume. Everyone believes their phones are listening. The refrigerator
is listening and watching to everything you consume.
…You can explain how programmatic ad personalization works until you're blue in the face and it is simpler to believe that the phones are listening to you, right? There's just nothing you can do about that. And that is all a function of the fact that there's no law saying you can't do it. So I think based on those mistakes, there's a lot of lawmakers who are like, okay, let's try this time. And importantly, there's not an Instagram of AI that people love. So a real problem with social media was the market never said, I don't like this. The market only ever said, I would like more Instagram, please. Right? The market only ever said, I'm actually super addicted to TikTok. And so the regulatory pressure never matched up with how consumers felt. Here, you just have this massive negative sentiment, right? Like people do not like this stuff. The kids hate AI like measurable ways and ways that are pulled again and again and again. You've got billionaires. You've got an election year. There's just…
for it. Why can't we get AI to production? Our competitors are already. How do we keep data secure? When do we actually see ROI? All this talk about AI, but talk doesn't transform businesses. AWS AI cuts through the noise, making AI easier to securely deploy and scale with ready-to-use agents and…
I want to go back to China, which you mentioned briefly, but so often it is cited as a reason to either not regulate or really try to not quote unquote fall behind, right? Is this this idea that we will fall behind China? Is that a legitimate concern in your opinion? Like, how should we be thinking…
I'm going to make a comparison here that you will find very funny, but I spent 10 years of my career as a tech journalist listening to telecom executives tell me that we had to win the race to 5G. We had to do it. We had to spend all of the money. And if China got to 5G first, then they would have…