SG Samuel Gregg On Capital Record

“Free marketers are very, very good at winning policy arguments, at making the arguments for efficiency and effectiveness. But time and time again, those who are opposed to markets, whether they're economic nationalists or democratic socialists, they're very high on making arguments grounded in a type of vision of a new society in which they think there'll be more justice, more freedom.”

Capital Record · Money & Markets · November 2026

“Free marketers are very, very good at winning policy arguments, at making the arguments for efficiency and effectiveness. But time and time again, those who are opposed to markets, whether they're economic nationalists or democratic socialists, they're very high on making arguments grounded in a type of vision of a new society in which they think there'll be more justice, more freedom.” — Samuel Gregg, Capital Record

Context

Asked for the core message of his new book, The Civilization of Commerce, Gregg says defenders of markets lean on efficiency arguments while their critics offer a picture of a better society. He thinks the case for markets needs to be made in broader terms.

Transcript

Capital Record Around 03:35 into the episode
Samuel Gregg

David, great to be with you.

David Bahnsen

…actually been quite fond of all, but I really do feel that this is magnificent work and the timing of it is impeccable in terms of the moment in history in which we find ourselves. But maybe you could tell the audience at a high level, what is the underlying message behind civilization of commerce?

Samuel Gregg

Well, first of all, David Bahnsen for having me on and thanks for the kind words about the book. For your listeners' sake, I suppose the most important thing that the book tries to do is to make the case that the case for the market economy, it goes beyond the economy. That in fact, if you go back to an older tradition of classical liberal thought, associated with people like, obviously, Adam Smith, but in more recent decades, people like F.A. Hayek. They clearly understood the case for the market economy to be one of a civilizational enterprise. They talked in terms of commercial society. That's certainly the language that Adam Smith used. He described commercial society as quote unquote a civilized society. If you read the works of F.A. Hayek, which I know you have, David, the word civilization appears everywhere. And I think it's because people of that caliber of thought understood that the market economy is not this thing that's just sitting somehow abstractly out of sight society. It's integral to a particular type of society. A society that I think was first identified by Scottish Enlightenment thinkers such as Adam Smith, but also people like David Hume, Francis…

David Bahnsen

So there's so much there to unpack. And that's what we're going to spend our time here together doing, Sam. But tell me what it is that you think slipped. What was the situation that kind of fell out of favor in terms of that case? Was it a political development? Was it something that unmoored…

Samuel Gregg

Well, there's a number of things that I think happened. So for example, among free marketers in the classical liberal world, if you look at when F.A. Hayek set up the Montpeleran Society, which is a group of classical liberal economists and historians and others who gathered together in Switzerland…

David Bahnsen

I think it might be helpful to distinguish. Of course, I have the advantage of having read the book and a lot of listeners have not. I think it would be news to people if you were saying this, and I know you're not, but I think it'd be news to people to hear that Milton Friedman, for example, did…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.