The Great Simplification with Nate Hagens · October 2026
Nate Hagens asked whether the oil shock from the Iran war would speed up or slow down the energy transition. Berman's answer is that biomass, coal, oil and gas were each layered on top of the last and none has ever declined, so investors betting on substitution are betting on something with no historical precedent. He adds that this doesn't mean it can't be done, only that the odds are low in the near term.
…we could absolutely run an economy, but not an economy that would support 8.2 billion people. It'd be a very different civilization, and in many ways, I think a better one. It's just that, you know, you don't get from here to there in a single step. I mean, you're talking about a long transition.
…expansion of coal? It's massive. What else? Resource nationalism, stockpiling, and different countries are doing different things. So what do you think this 2026 Iran war energy shock could be setting in motion? And does the shock speed up or slow down the so-called energy transition story?
…stopped using biomass. We simply layered on coal on top of it. But as a world, we have, at the very least, over the last 20 or 30 years, we've actually, we've kept our coal consumption flat or increased it slightly. So biomass, we never decreased it. Coal, we never decreased it. Then we got oil and we added that on top and that's never decreased. Natural gas came later. That's never decreased. Hydro, nuclear, all those things, we kept adding them on top of each other. We never transitioned from anything to anything. I'm not bringing this up because it's a semantic problem. It's that the entire mindset that our investment world is in is one of substitution. We're going to substitute renewables or EVs or whatever for our current system. And yet there's no historical precedent for ever doing that. That doesn't mean that you can't do it. It just means that the probability is quite low. And certainly the…
What's this going to change?
I mean, everything has changed. We just don't know it yet. And so what I think is most probable is that we'll see a run-up in prices, which we're seeing right now. We're going to see demand destruction. It'll vary from place to place, depending on the capacity of that location to get its supply…
What about U.S. shale? What's happened since February? What did U.S. shale do in response to this crisis? What didn't it do? And what does that imply about shale for the next five years?