JS John Siracusa John Siracusa Software developer, writer and podcaster who spent 25 years as a full-stack web developer before going independent in 2022.

“If you give an AI coding agent or AI agent of any kind access to your Mac, not only can it do all the things listed on the sheet and more, that's kind of the point of that app. … Unless it's nefarious, a window-shade utility window-shades your windows. But what does an AI coding agent do? Anything.”

Accidental Tech Podcast · Tech Strategy & Big Tech · November 2026

“If you give an AI coding agent or AI agent of any kind access to your Mac, not only can it do all the things listed on the sheet and more, that's kind of the point of that app. … Unless it's nefarious, a window-shade utility window-shades your windows. But what does an AI coding agent do? Anything.” — John Siracusa, Accidental Tech Podcast

Context

John was going through the reworked permission screens in the macOS 27.3 beta. He says the permissions aren't granular, and that the warning sheet matters most for AI agent apps, which need broad control of the machine.

Transcript

Accidental Tech Podcast Around 1:13:40 into the episode
John Siracusa

This is what Apple wrote.

Casey Liss

…app permissions previously granted by users will remain in effect. And again, there is a developer, like it's not newsroom, but like a newsroom post about it. And then additionally, there's a support document, which has a bunch of screenshots. John, would you mind taking us through this, please?

John Siracusa

Yeah. So that description, when they first just released that thing with those bullet points, I'm like, what are you doing? Like, how does this make any sense? And as you fumbled over reading this, like system ampersand app protection override does not roll off the tongue, but they're trying to give things different names. And that is accessibility. And anyway, they renamed a bunch of stuff, which means everybody's instructions for how to give their apps permissions now have to change because everything, every place you told them to go before when 27.3 comes out, those things won't be there, although it'll be called something different. But anyway. This is what this looks like in practice. So, for full disk access, they still give that the same name. But now, when you go to give an app full disk access, they made a bunch of changes. I think this is true of the other one, but I think it's also true of full disk access. The first thing I think they did was don't let you drag apps into the system settings window anymore, which is a thing that a lot of apps like they have like little…

Marco Arment

location history from your photos.

John Siracusa

Right. Like, so they're giving concrete examples to communicate to people, to talk to them in a way that they will understand. Again, not because these are specific things that like you, this is just, it's, it's still like one checkbox, one toggle. But when you check that one toggle, here are all…

Marco Arment

I see every step of the way that gets them to this solution. Like I understand how they got here, but where they are is a mess. First of all, adding more and more words to all of these titles and divisions does not make it easier to read or more likely anybody will read it. It seems like they're…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Accidental Tech Podcast