MA Marco Arment Marco Arment Software developer and podcaster, creator of the podcast app Overcast and the earlier read-later app Instapaper.

“When you say, hey, Dingus, set a timer for five minutes, that should not go to the cloud for anything. That should be recognized instantly with an on-device model. And that model should be smart enough to figure out if it has low confidence in what you're asking. Okay, this should go to the cloud. … Timers. Make timers awesome because that's what people use these products for.”

Accidental Tech Podcast · Tech Strategy & Big Tech · November 2026

“When you say, hey, Dingus, set a timer for five minutes, that should not go to the cloud for anything. That should be recognized instantly with an on-device model. And that model should be smart enough to figure out if it has low confidence in what you're asking. Okay, this should go to the cloud. … Timers. Make timers awesome because that's what people use these products for.” — Marco Arment, Accidental Tech Podcast

Context

Marco was listing what Apple would have to do to make HomeView a good product. He says smart displays are mostly kitchen-timer devices, and that a small on-device model could handle timers and send harder questions to the cloud.

Transcript

Accidental Tech Podcast Around 1:39:37 into the episode
Marco Arment

And by the way, if what you want is the best sounding countertop speaker in approximately this size, it's still the home pod, like the full-size one. I hope they don't kill it.

John Siracusa

…know, once you for $300, like you're comparing to the big home pod, the big home pods are not $300 and they don't have a screen. So it's kind of not a fair fight. So I think it does an okay job for its size and cost in terms of the sound quality. But yeah, it's not an audio file speaker for sure.

Marco Arment

…right at your fingertips of features and everything, the faster you can get used to it. The better you can use it with like, you know, wet hands or by voice or whatever. Okay. Number two, give it a local model that can instantly recognize timers. These devices, we've learned like smart speakers and smart displays with speakers like this, these are kitchen devices for many, many, many people. When you say, hey, Dingus, set a timer for five minutes, that should not go to the cloud for anything. That should be recognized instantly with an on-device model. And that model should be smart enough to figure out if it has low confidence in what you're asking. Okay, this should go to the cloud. This is not a question for me. But timers, maybe even reminders, but that might be a stretch for Apple. Timers. Make timers awesome because that's what people use these products for. Give named multiple timers, make them show up nicely in the UI, not just the big Apple Watch app, but make them show up nicely in the UI, optimize it for that screen, and give it that local model so that when you…

John Siracusa

you're assuming that they're not already doing this because it's slow. I know why you would make that assumption, but I'm not entirely sure that they're not already doing it locally and it's slow for other reasons. It seems inconceivable that it would be local because again, if you implement, like…

Casey Liss

Nope. Nope. Not even a little bit.

John Siracusa

You may have the most home kit stuff, though. Maybe you get one of the wall-mounted ones and just so you can have like a little thermostat and a thing that's better than a bunch of lightup LCDs to tell you whether your garage is door is open. Although, I guess you'd probably have to make your own…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Accidental Tech Podcast