MA Marco Arment Marco Arment Software developer and podcaster, creator of the podcast app Overcast and the earlier read-later app Instapaper.

“This is one of those situations where Apple is really not at their A-game. This product is software-wise a mess. But because everyone else in this category has such crappy products, their product is going to get away with being a mess, but still being better than everyone else's.”

Accidental Tech Podcast · Tech Strategy & Big Tech · November 2026

“This is one of those situations where Apple is really not at their A-game. This product is software-wise a mess. But because everyone else in this category has such crappy products, their product is going to get away with being a mess, but still being better than everyone else's.” — Marco Arment, Accidental Tech Podcast

Context

After a few days with HomeView, Apple's new $300 home display, Marco gives his verdict. He compares its jumbled interface to the Pocket PC era, when Microsoft shrank its desktop UI onto a handheld.

Transcript

Accidental Tech Podcast Around 1:27:00 into the episode
Marco Arment

…software. Like some of it works like an Apple Watch. Some of it works like Apple TV. Some of it works like an iPhone or an iPad. There's all these different mixed UI paradigms and metaphors, and there's different modes and stuff that it can be in. What it reminds me of, honestly, is Pocket PC.

Casey Liss

That's a throwback.

Marco Arment

In like the PDA days, the early 2000s PDA wave, right before smartphones really became a thing. In retrospect, everyone loves the iPhone, but then was criticizing Windows because what Microsoft did was when they made Pocket PC was they basically made a PDA that looked a little bit like Windows 95's UI. It had the start button in the corner of like the home screen or the PDA and you would tap with the stylus and you'd tap the start button and you'd find your app and you'd tap it in there. I had one. It was fine. Same. In retrospect, everybody was like, yeah, that was not the right move. They took what they had. They had the start button. They had that paradigm. They took what they had and just shrunk it down and said, all right, we're done. The home view feels kind of like that. It feels like they have all these mechanisms they've built up over time with their popular platforms. And they just think, okay, well, now that we have this other form factor, this other device family, what parts of that do we pick? Choose to shove onto here. And it really just feels like…

John Siracusa

So I echo some of the things you said. Let's start with the hardware. It is smaller than I thought it would be. Not that I knew what size it was, but when you see it in person, you're like, oh, that is a little bit smaller. And in particular, the screen is pretty small. I mean, the whole thing is…

Marco Arment

right up your nose.

John Siracusa

I have to like tilt it so that because the screen tilts, obviously, I have to tilt it so the screen is basically facing the ceiling or I'm not in the circle. Like, you know, who is who is putting this with it with the screen? Like in all the screenshots, the screen is like, it's not vertical, but…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Accidental Tech Podcast