Decoder with Nilay Patel · Tech Strategy & Big Tech · November 2026
New Jersey's governor had described regulating AI through data center rules and social media through child-safety laws. Patel points out that regulating AI so far means regulating buildings, while regulating social media runs into free speech law.
I'm glad you brought up this trade-off. So many of your peers that have shown up on the show have basically offered me the formulation of we failed to regulate social media. We will not fail to regulate AI. Like that is the dynamic I've heard from. So we're
just giving up on social media?
Well, I would say we got to social media regulation 10 years later. We didn't do it through acts of Congress. We didn't pass a federal privacy bill. Like these things don't exist. We got there through major litigation, which your state has participated in, and a bunch of state-level laws that recapitulate parts of the Kids Online Safety Act, right? And whenever I hear this formulation, the thing that I think is, well, it's way easier to regulate AI because they want to build huge buildings. And if there's one thing Americans can do, it's stop you from building huge buildings. Like, we are good at that. We're great at that. Maybe that's not the right tool, but boy, are we good at swinging that hammer? Everything about social media is speech, right? Everything about social media affects the First Amendment in some big and meaningful way. And we've never figured out how to have that conversation directly. We tend to have conversations about Section 230. Like we find other things that you can knock around so you don't have to talk about. Well, ultimately, we are restricting how teens can speak…
We're actually not going at it from a speech restriction specifically, partly because we've seen this in the courts. Now, do I think that young children should be seeing hardcore porn? And do I think we should be able to restrict that? Yes. However, given some of what we've seen in the court cases…
Yeah, and that's the 10 years of figuring it out. We essentially across the country have landed on product liability and not content moderation, right? The product is designed to be harmful. We're not even going to talk about the content because then you will run into the First Amendment. There are…
Do you really think you're anonymous online? Like, I guess I don't believe that you're anonymous online.