GP Gene Park On The Bulwark

“I do think video game journalism is certainly dying. I don't think there's a broad market for it right now, despite the popularity of video games, mostly because a lot of the video game criticism lives on YouTube and podcasts. Video games are a very visual medium. They're very interactive.”

The Bulwark · Policy · November 2026

“I do think video game journalism is certainly dying. I don't think there's a broad market for it right now, despite the popularity of video games, mostly because a lot of the video game criticism lives on YouTube and podcasts. Video games are a very visual medium. They're very interactive.” — Gene Park, The Bulwark

Context

Bunch asked why games criticism is so thin given how big the medium is. Park argues the best criticism has moved to video, which shows play better than written reviews can.

Transcript

The Bulwark
Gene Park

…cost a billion dollars. And when you look at the game, you're like, this has to cost at least a billion dollars. This is a rocket ship. This is a spaceship that they made. Spaceships do cost a billion dollars to make. This is what they made. This is the moonlanding of video games, quite honestly.

Sonny Bunch

…a useful metric that people who actually play video games, you know, kind of use. But in terms of the broader cultural conversation, it does feel like there is some question as to like how this is discussed, who is discussing it, the extent to which it's being discussed. What's your take on things?

Gene Park

Deeply complicated topic. But, you know, there is no London review of games. I think partially because games are hard to get into. It is a literacy thing. The only way you can actually engage critically with a video game is if you know how to play it. And to be able to know how to play a video game, this is how you read a game. You pick up a controller and you have to figure out what buttons to do. And each game has its own language, basically. That's why we call a design language in video games. So it is very, very difficult to grasp wrong. You call me the greatest video game critic. I'm flattered. I love that. I agree too. But it's hard. Even I can't wrap my head around certain types of genres or games. I will not call myself an expert in every single type of game or even every single type of design philosophy. So imagine taking that level of expertise that you need and applying that to your Bob Woodwards or your Ben Bradleys or whatever. Old journalists, boomer journalists who wouldn't even engage in rap music in good faith. So it really does come down to generations.…

Sonny Bunch

Well, this has always been My theory on why game criticism has trouble compared to other forms, right? Which is that other forms of art are essentially dictatorial. You have a film and the film is there. And like, you may feel different ways about it, but the film is the film. The album is the…

Gene Park

That goes straight to the heart of Roger Ebert's argument about why he famously argued that he doesn't believe video games are art because it is so moldable to the audience's whims that he doesn't believe there could be meaningful criticism out of it. And unfortunately, and I'm not saying this as a…

Sonny Bunch

Well, let's bring this to me then, because I like to make everything about me. There were some folks who said, hey, where is the Bulwark going to write a review? And that's the sort of thing that would fall on me to write a review of Grand Theft Auto VI. And I was just like, I can't. I can't…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from The Bulwark