HM Hamish McKenzie Hamish McKenzie Co-founder of Substack and its Chief Writing Officer, the role in which he represents writers' interests inside the company.

“The incentive system for X is to keep people addicted to the feed so they never leave it, so you can show more ads to them. The incentive system for Substack is to try and get more subscribers for more creators, because that's the only way we make money and it's what the creators want too. When you have 'how do we get more trust relationships going' as the guiding principle for the algorithm, you get a different cultural outcome.”

Sinocism (Bill Bishop) · Geopolitics & World Affairs · November 2026

“The incentive system for X is to keep people addicted to the feed so they never leave it, so you can show more ads to them. The incentive system for Substack is to try and get more subscribers for more creators, because that's the only way we make money and it's what the creators want too. When you have 'how do we get more trust relationships going' as the guiding principle for the algorithm, you get a different cultural outcome.” — Hamish McKenzie, Sinocism (Bill Bishop)

Context

The host asked whether Substack Notes is working, saying he is always in a worse mood after time on X. He answers that Notes looks like a feed but behaves differently because the business model is different.

Transcript

Sinocism (Bill Bishop)
Hamish McKenzie

Notes is the number one growth source. Yeah.

Bill Bishop

It's working for me.

Hamish McKenzie

So yes, it's working for the creators in terms of driving them audiences. And then I think it's working as a product in its own right, as like it's an interesting place to hang out and get a taste of different people's minds. And I think people's relationship with Notes is different from X or Twitter, even though it looks like a feed of short form content. Like it's aesthetically similar, but the cultural effect is different. On Twitter, I'm like mainlining content bits and fights and arguments. And on Notes, I'm getting more of an understanding of the world and engaging with it more as there are real people behind these thoughts and ideas. And this is one way that they're showing us that they're real people and seeking connection and we can choose whether or not to connect. And they're also usually nicer. Usually, yeah. The incentive system changes everything. The incentive system for X is to keep people addicted to the feed so they never leave it so you can show more ads to them. The incentive system for Self Stack is try and get more subscribers for more creators because that's the only way we make money and it's what the creators want too. And when you have how do we get more trust relationships going as the…

Bill Bishop

I mean, it's interesting on X. I mean, I have a couple hundred thousand followers. I've had a blue check since before, you know, before you had to pay. And I occasionally run, you know, I'll post, sometimes I run specials, you know, 30% off whatever, and I'll post a link on X, and sometimes I'll…

Hamish McKenzie

I think it's at least like so much of X is not real. So much of X now is content made by bots posing as humans in the replies, in the top line posts, everything. So much, like a huge percentage of that. But I think the worst, not that, okay, maybe it's not so much a crime, but the more prevalent…

Bill Bishop

So the Bill Ackman long text post is not, I mean, it's true. When I use notes, I mean, again, you get comments and you go see what else this person said, right? And it's so far, at least, notes doesn't have a lot of bots. And I'm sure they've tried. And I think you've cleaned them out over time.…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Sinocism (Bill Bishop)