Search Engine · Tech Strategy & Big Tech · November 2026
A listener asked whether Search Engine has been soft on AI companies and dismissive of data center protesters. PJ rejects the view that AI is a hoax like crypto and explains how he thinks the show should cover it.
…they want is that this is a flash in the pan thing that's going to go away. That's the only part of the debate that I'm like, I just think the evidence doesn't support it. I don't want to spend time engaging with it. There's plenty of media that does support that idea and like you can find it.
And when you say flash in the pan, you mean people who think that AI is a hoax, like it's like crypto. Like it's not a useful technology. It never will be. No
one's really going to use it. It's going to stop tomorrow. And I think that's like diminishing, but I used to get a lot of that in my inbox. I'm just like, it's just not what I believe. And I don't think it's responsible to cover it that way. I think the way to responsibly cover it is this could absolutely be a financial bubble, but the technology is here. It's going to be transformative. It will be transformed in ways that are bad. Hopefully, it'll be transformed in ways that are good. And our job is to be really curious about it, explain it to our audiences so they can make up their minds. My biggest feeling with AI, my biggest critique of it is that it feels profoundly undemocratic. Like it feels like change that's being foisted by a few unusual people on like our entire society. And so my understanding of how to participate in this democracy is to try to provide information and ask questions. So that's what we're trying to do.
Yeah. And one other thing I want to say to this person is that it's tricky because while we don't always do a deep dive on the Reddit criticism of specific episodes, I have noticed that sometimes Reddit can be very harsh on an AI episode, but then we get like a lot of listeners writing in to say…
what we see our job as this year is more like doing explainers and less like making predictions about what's going to happen. And I do think, I think you're right, Truthy. Like I think that the Reddit view on AI and the view on our inbox and AI, Reply different. Both views are concerned, but it's a…
Okay. From Conscious Food 9828. Hi, PJ. Love the show. Do you have a quote heartbreak story that after much work, time and effort, never quite planned out, never quite panned out? I think this person means.