BB Ben Buchanan On Plain English with Derek Thompson

“Take the word of Howard Lutnick, the man at the center of this scandal, who testified in 2025 that China, all of China, could only make 200,000 chips. And each of those chips is something like one-fifth as good as a cutting-edge NVIDIA chip. That's not enough, 200,000 for even a single data center.”

Plain English with Derek Thompson · US Politics · November 2026

“Take the word of Howard Lutnick, the man at the center of this scandal, who testified in 2025 that China, all of China, could only make 200,000 chips. And each of those chips is something like one-fifth as good as a cutting-edge NVIDIA chip. That's not enough, 200,000 for even a single data center.” — Ben Buchanan, Plain English with Derek Thompson

Context

Derek had just made Nvidia's argument: cut China off and Huawei will build its own chips and win the infrastructure race. Ben answers that China cannot make chips at scale, using the Commerce Secretary's own testimony.

Transcript

Plain English with Derek Thompson Around 39:19 into the episode
Ben Buchanan

…an NVIDIA defense attorney here is not just whatever happened in the MegaSpeed case, but the broader theme that smuggling is a huge issue. And we, as I think, a national security community need to stop it and need to really up the enforcement. That strikes me as just really obvious at this point.

Derek Thompson

…America weaker. You guys are fighting to protect a law that is imprudently making America poorer in the long run because of this diseased assumption that AI is a machine god rather than just the next electricity. Ben, as an administration alum, as someone who advises for Anthropic, why am I wrong?

Ben Buchanan

…Biden administration comes in. We don't just cut them off from chips. We also cut them off from chip manufacturing equipment the next year down, a portion of it called deep ultraviolet lithography. That hurts them further. And the net result is, even with pretty lax enforcement of these controls by the second Trump term, China still struggles to make chips. You don't have to take my word for it. Take the word of Howard Lutnick, the man at the center of this scandal, who testified in 2025 that China, all of China, could only make 200,000 chips. And each of those chips is something like one-fifth as good as a cutting-edge NVIDIA chip. That's not enough, 200,000 for even a single data center. So the notion that China could somehow run its own AI industry off domestically produced trips, the notion that China could somehow run its own AI industry off domestically produced chips is fanciful. Even more fanciful is the notion that somehow China is going to export this all over the world. They simply cannot make the chips. Again, there's never been a Chinese model trained on Chinese…

Derek Thompson

Jordan?

Jordan Schneider

You know, you're a theater nerd. So I want to start to bring in the Shakespeare as we come to the end of this episode. Tis the sport to have the engineer hoist with his own petard. I mean, this is the fundamental tragedy of all of this: is that Jensen, the only like Jensen started out as a gaming…

Derek Thompson

Ben, what makes this story so interesting to me is that you can engage with it as a news consumer from so many different layers. If you're just interested in the sex scandal, it answers your questions there. If you're interested in the question of corporate espionage, the smuggling of one of the…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Plain English with Derek Thompson