JG James Gleick On a16z Podcast

“It was natural, when the telephone started to arrive, to think of it as a kind of extension of the telegraph. It was the telegraph, but you add voice. And a lot of people made that mistake, including the president of Western Union, which had something close to a telegraph monopoly, who was offered the first patent for the telephone and said, that's just a toy. What use could I possibly make of that?”

a16z Podcast · Startups & Venture · November 2026

“It was natural, when the telephone started to arrive, to think of it as a kind of extension of the telegraph. It was the telegraph, but you add voice. And a lot of people made that mistake, including the president of Western Union, which had something close to a telegraph monopoly, who was offered the first patent for the telephone and said, that's just a toy. What use could I possibly make of that?” — James Gleick, a16z Podcast

Context

James Gleick describes how incumbents saw the telephone through the lens of the telegraph and missed what was new about it. It's a familiar pattern for anyone watching how established companies size up AI.

Transcript

a16z Podcast Around 02:56 into the episode
Sonal Chokshi

…of course, there's the science that Bell Labs created around the telephone. So, this is a very rich book. And I think we'll just jump right into it by talking about the telephone as a device, kind of a network, and then more broadly, the innovation process and backstory. So, James, ahoy. Ahoy.

Robert Hackett

…what happened. It's more interesting, more complex than that. There was prior precedent. There were competing claims to the invention. So I thought maybe you could just kind of describe some of what you found when you looked into this in doing this archaeology, this excavation of telephony.

James Gleick

It's true. And we know a world where sending your voice long distances is completely unremarkable. I mean, we're using a telephone right now. We're very far apart geographically. We are speaking and creating sound waves in the room, and the sound waves are being converted into electricity. And almost instantaneously, you are hearing what I'm saying because the electricity is reconverted into sound waves at your end. And that is the telephone idea. And it didn't exist. I mean, people always dreamed of being able to communicate across long distances, but there was no practical way to do that until the telegraph arrived. And then the telegraph, in the time of which we speak, was rapidly transforming the world. Everybody understood how important it was. It was making a lot of money. Wires were crisscrossing the United States, and people were sending messages electrically. So that was fantastic. And so it was natural. When the telephone started to arrive, to think of it as a kind of extension of the telegraph, something new. It was the telegraph, but you add voice. And a lot of people made that mistake, including the president of Western Union, which had something close to a telegraph…

Robert Hackett

It's funny because this is exactly what Thomas Edison thought the first uses of the phonograph were going to be. He was like, oh, people are going to love to hear the sermons. They're going to love to hear concerts and stuff. But yeah, it ended up being rock music and jazz that kind of caught on…

James Gleick

so that was what Edison's musical taste would have been like if he were alive today. That's true. And of course, the phonograph came along right after the telephone. I mean, it was hard on its heels. And that's not an accident because everybody was figuring out how to make connections between…

Robert Hackett

I've got to say, the German man in Frankfurt using sausage casings to make this device is just like, you couldn't make this stuff up. It's just too rich.

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from a16z Podcast