Scaling Laws · October 2026
Landemore has proposed using the AI labs' own chatbots, which reach huge numbers of people directly, to consult the public on how AI should be governed. She was answering the objection that the scheme has flaws and hands the labs too much power. Her reply is that it should be judged against the status quo and not against an ideal world.
…of like maximizing their wages. But it's different from being involved at the level of the corporation where you're an actor and not just an input in the production chain, right? So for me, this conversation also needs to be connected. And it's like it's an agenda for the next 50 years. I mean,
…some of these critical decisions. And I'm not saying that board meetings should be broadcast via Zoom or YouTube or something like that. But there needs to be an opportunity such that there's friction in how and when some of the most consequential decisions are going to be made by these companies.
…about when I'm saying we should even rethink capitalism broadly, but it would be a beginning of something, it would be better than a status quo. And to go back to the beginning of our conversation, when you rightly pointed out, okay, your scheme has flaws, but at least compared to the status quo, it's something. I think that's the point. You can always compare any proposal to an ideal world. But if we don't have at least some sort of public consultation through LLMs right now, what we're going to get is the tyranny of Silicon Valley CEOs and a few experts and maybe a few government heads around the world. Is that really the best we can do? I don't think so.
Yeah, and I think, too, there's so much to remembering first principles in these conversations. Again, I'm sure some listeners are at this point ready to throw their phone into the ocean. We've questioned capitalism. We've questioned Congress. They're just, wow, this is a radical episode. But if we…
Well, yes, I think we've seen some attacks on like Sansa Maltman. It's looking like a sort of populist rebellion in the making. But I would say, even if we don't see that violence, I hate when we have to wait for violence to do anything. In France, too, we had to have the yellow vest movement and…
Yeah, what a fascinating provocation because I was just reading before this some scholarship from Jillian Hadfield looking at how important it is for society and for cooperative action to have sanction and to have clear penalties. And it's compliance with those penalties and enforcement of those…