DA Daron Acemoglu On Into the Impossible With Brian Keating

“You can't have it both ways, Brian. The tech industry tells us that AI is the most important technology since fire. It will shape every aspect of our lives. It will completely transform everything we do. But then they're also telling us, stay out and let this be decided by a handful of people.”

Into the Impossible With Brian Keating · Ideas & Essays · October 2026

“You can't have it both ways, Brian. The tech industry tells us that AI is the most important technology since fire. It will shape every aspect of our lives. It will completely transform everything we do. But then they're also telling us, stay out and let this be decided by a handful of people.” — Daron Acemoglu, Into the Impossible With Brian Keating

Context

Acemoglu had been arguing that whether AI replaces workers or gives them new capabilities is a design decision, and that the industry is currently betting everything on replacement. His conclusion was that a technology this consequential has to go through democratic debate and regulation.

Transcript

Into the Impossible With Brian Keating Around 26:29 into the episode
Daron Acemoglu

It should be.

Brian Keating

Okay, so explain that argument. Yeah. How could it be there? What example? Use teaching. Use teaching as an

Daron Acemoglu

…and socially more beneficial. But I'm not saying that that's necessarily going to happen because whether we do that or not is a design decision. And right now, we're putting all of our design eggs in the AGI basket. So this is why I think we need a framework for the regulation of AI and support for AI from government entities. But even more importantly, we need a democratic debate on AI. You can't have it both ways, Brian. The tech industry tells us that AI is the most important technology since fire. It will shape every aspect of our lives. It will completely transform everything we do. But then they're also telling us, stay out and let this be decided by a handful of people. That can't be, if it's half as important, a quarter as important as they say. It's the most important thing that has happened to us in the last 100 years. And therefore, of course, the democratic process must have a say in how we develop AI, how we use it, what we do with it, who benefits from it, who pays the cost. That's a democratic decision. We are still a democracy, perhaps not for long…

Brian Keating

Today you tweeted about the alignment problem, which I've talked a lot about with people from Jan Lacun to Max Tegmark to Nobel laureates as well. But the question that you raise is that the problem that people are mistaking is not the capabilities, as you say. The capabilities are real. But more…

Daron Acemoglu

Look, I refuse that control. I'm not an expert on AI. But my assessment is. That there are so many good things we can do with domain-specific models. You want to use AI in the production process, but better quality control, better design, better training, make the workers more productive. All of…

Brian Keating

All right, Duron, I know you got to go, but I have one more question for you. Please. I want to leave you with a line that I think is quite beautiful. I'm sure you've known it your whole life because it comes from Ataturk. He said, For civilization, for life and for success, the truest guide is…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Into the Impossible With Brian Keating