Planet Money · Money & Markets · November 2026
Dawn Foster, a longtime insurance agent in Paradise, California, on the discounts insurers give for wildfire-proofing a home. She says the savings come nowhere near the cost.
Some are a 1% discount, some are 10%. It was just all over the place. So there's no consistency to even tell a homeowner, do this, and this happens. The best we could say was, do this, and hopefully it will pay off.
And Dawn Foster, the local insurance agent in Paradise, agrees. She says the discounts and insurance premiums have not come anywhere close to offsetting the costs.
I have not seen one carrier give higher than a 5% discount for hardening your home. So I have clients that spent upwards to $17,000 because their home survived and they wanted to keep their carrier and do all of these changes to their home, replace their siding with cement board, everything, $17 grand to get a $42 discount off of their policy.
It seems like then it's not really incentivizing you to harden your home.
Not at all. Not at all.
Jenny says, despite everything she was doing, everything the town was doing, more and more people in Paradise were still getting kicked off or priced out of the private insurance market. What kind of sense were you making of that?