The Vergecast · Tech Strategy & Big Tech · November 2026
The discussion was about big US school districts weighing alternatives to Google after Google declined to offer schools Search without AI features. Nilay Patel argues AI is unusual because its success destroys the incentive to publish the information it depends on.
So if you make a car and you get really successful, it is unlikely that you will put the car seat vendor out of business. Car seat vendor is probably going to like, that's normal.
Yeah.
AI is the only product where if it gets really successful, it kills the supply of information by making it not economically viable. And so like Google has killed the supply of information to search. It's made search not as valuable as it used to be. And so now they're pointing a gun being like, you can't have search unless you have AI. And a bunch of big customers like, well, your search sucks. Yeah. What if we try another search? And it's just like remarkable Google didn't see that endpoint of monopoly.
Yeah, it's the real, what are you going to do? Leave that is actually, it's very important that your product be hard to leave in a way that I'm not sure Google search is hard to leave. Google Classroom and Chromebooks and stuff like that will be hard to leave, but you've got to figure there are…
Right.
Like I suspect, and again, I keep thinking about Satya Nadella being like, we are just desperate for queries because it makes our search engine bigger. Like Satya Nadella is going to run around to every school district in the country being like, we'll give you Bing for free. Do you want Bing for…