Platypus Economics with Justin Wolfers · Money & Markets · October 2026
Wolfers was asked why the monthly jobs numbers get revised, which looks to a non-expert like the report is never right. He explained that a revision is what happens when more employers send back their survey forms.
I'm Justin Wolfers. I'm a professor of economics. That's why we call this the professor is in. But what I want you to think about it is this is when Augusta brings me your questions, just like it's office hours. Augusta, coming into my office.
…down from previous estimations. Can you talk a little bit about why that was and what that means? Because from the perspective of a non-expert, it's really confusing that like the jobs report is never quite accurate and sometimes it's totally different months later. What are we looking at here?
…a revision is. We move from having an incomplete sample to a somewhat more complete sample. And then a month later, an even more complete sample. So first thing, there are people who try to undermine the public's faith in government statistics. They do that, I think, because they want to undermine yours and my faith in the idea that there is a truth. I'm deeply dismayed by that. But actually, a statistical agency that revises its data is much better than one that doesn't. Just like a person who admits their mistakes is much better than one who doesn't. You might be tempted to say, well, the first print was high and the second print was low. So maybe the truth is in between. That's not right. The first print was based on a small sample. The second print includes all those people and also includes others. So therefore, there's no extra information in the initial number than in the revised number. The revised number is always and everywhere a better guide to what's going on. So far from being. A weakness of our statistical authorities. It's a strength that they revise. And one of the things we learned this month was that the folks who sent back their forms early last month were the folks who'd…
Okay, let's talk about healthcare because the story for a long time at this point has been that we're adding jobs in the healthcare sector and it's one of the only places where we're adding jobs. And I just want to pull back from this data and talk about when this huge uptake in healthcare jobs…
Yeah, I think it's an incredibly important thing. So the first thing I want to do, because all professors mutter about their own thoughts first before answering their students' questions, is mutter a little bit. I want you to notice almost all the hiring, essentially all, actually more than all of…
You are always seeing me there, aren't you?