JC Jess Carbino On The Checkup with Doctor Mike

“The jam isn't choosing you. You're choosing it. That's not a bi-directional relationship. In the real world, you swipe on 100 people in a given day, … you swipe right on 20, you match with 10, you message with five, and then you go out with two. Only one of them likes you, and you only like one of them back. So really, the choices that you had were not quite as infinite as you imagined.”

The Checkup with Doctor Mike · Health & Longevity · November 2026

“The jam isn't choosing you. You're choosing it. That's not a bi-directional relationship. In the real world, you swipe on 100 people in a given day, … you swipe right on 20, you match with 10, you message with five, and then you go out with two. Only one of them likes you, and you only like one of them back. So really, the choices that you had were not quite as infinite as you imagined.” — Jess Carbino, The Checkup with Doctor Mike

Context

She was arguing that people misapply the "too many choices" research to dating apps, since that research used consumer examples like jars of jam. A partner choice has to be mutual, and the funnel from swipes to a date is much narrower than it feels.

Transcript

The Checkup with Doctor Mike Around 11:32 into the episode
Jess Carbino

Their early experiences make it scary. Being known was something that was probably tied up in punishment or there wasn't a reward associated with it. Like being known was dismissed, for example. Interesting. And that's something I observe all the time with patients.

Mike Varshavski

And when you say that the idea of this friction helping people grow, dating apps, much like most technological products, aim to remove friction. Are dating apps removing the good part of dating?

Jess Carbino

No, I think they introduce a lot of friction, to be candid with you. Well, because people introduce the friction. Dating apps theoretically try to remove it, but there are humans involved. They can't remove everything. And I think that's why the idea of choice and how people perceive choice on dating apps is not necessarily correct. So people have sat with me for years and said, you know, there are too many choices on dating apps, but I think they're thinking about the choice incorrectly. Because when we thought about choice in a theoretical way or when psychologists have talked about it, like Barry Schwartz, for example, or Ambody and Iengar, all those people who've written about it widely, they were using consumer-related choices. Like jars of jam was the classic example. And so when you walk into a supermarket, if you have enough money and you don't have an allergy to something, you know, the choice of jam that you make isn't going to have a huge consequence for your life like a partner would, for example. And moreover, the jam isn't choosing you. You know, you're choosing it. That's not a bi-directional relationship. And let's say in the real world, like you swipe…

Mike Varshavski

Is that why also some of the technology leads to unhappiness?

Jess Carbino

I think that could be a role in it. Technology, I think, could lead to unhappiness because it doesn't provide us with these developmental tasks that we need to engage in. We need to continue our development over time. Friction's part of that. And I think that if you're not daily or weekly engaging…

Mike Varshavski

Or just have relationships. Yeah. Because the lonely geriatric patient of mine has a higher likelihood of developing Alzheimer's, shortened lifespans, et cetera.

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from The Checkup with Doctor Mike