The Indicator (Planet Money) · Money & Markets · November 2026
After explaining a proposed tribal water settlement and the states blocking it, the hosts turned to the economics. This is why Colorado River water isn't priced or allocated like a scarce resource.
We're at their mercy and, you know, begging for something which we are entitled to. And I just hope that somebody up there will listen to us and help us out that we get this settlement passed.
But there's something else at play if the settlement deal passes. Economists say it's not just about water rights for these three tribes.
They say there's actually an economic lesson here about the value of water. Even though it's a really precious resource, it's not always priced like one. We've covered this a couple of times on the indicator. In the Colorado River case, it's a precious and shrinking resource that a lot of Western states, plus Mexico, rely on. The big thing to know here is that access to the Colorado River is often decided by who started using water first. Not who can pay the most for it, not who is using it the best or most efficiently, just who's been using it the longest.
That often leaves farms as the oldest and most legally untouchable water users. Some of that farming is pivotal. The reason you can eat a salad in the winter all across the country, that's because a huge majority of our nation's winter vegetables are grown with water from the Colorado River.
But big portions of that water are also used to grow stuff like alfalfa hay, which is used to feed cows. That hay takes a lot of water to grow, and cells were relatively cheap.
So with agriculture using about three quarters of all the water from the Colorado River, that means a lot of the precious resource is being used really inefficiently.