ML Michael Liebreich Michael Liebreich Host of Cleaning Up.

“Measuring energy demand in primary energy is about as useful as measuring nutrition in acres because it's the input to the system. And if we're enormously inefficient and we waste most primary energy, which we do, then it's similar to saying, well, Africa may have vast amounts of acres under cultivation, but it's no good if it doesn't get to people and provide the nutritional needs.”

Everything Electric Podcast · Climate & Energy · October 2026

“Measuring energy demand in primary energy is about as useful as measuring nutrition in acres because it's the input to the system. And if we're enormously inefficient and we waste most primary energy, which we do, then it's similar to saying, well, Africa may have vast amounts of acres under cultivation, but it's no good if it doesn't get to people and provide the nutritional needs.” — Michael Liebreich, Everything Electric Podcast

Context

Liebreich was describing what he calls the primary energy fallacy: adding up all the fuel going into an economy and treating the total as the amount that needs replacing. His argument is that what counts is the useful energy that reaches the end use.

Transcript

Everything Electric Podcast Around 18:06 into the episode
Michael Liebreich

…And in fact, last year, very interestingly, both wind and solar, each individually, overtook nuclear power output. And together, they overtook gas, which I bet not many people know. If you put wind and solar together, there's more electricity produced from them than there is now from natural gas.

Helen Czerski

…of, I think we're going to have to get a lot better at understanding where energy actually is and isn't and where useful energy is, which is obviously what really matters. It's not about how much energy there is. It's about how much useful energy is accessible. And those are different things.

Michael Liebreich

Absolutely. And I'm doing a lot of thinking about this. And I very much look forward to your book because I'm sure it'll enlighten enormously. Because I do a lot of work on trying to educate people about things like what I call the primary energy fallacy, right? If you just add up all the energy that goes into our economy and you get a number in joules or in, you know, it doesn't, you can do it in any unit. You can do it in millions of barrels of oil equivalent or petajoules or whatever. But it's so many different resources added together that it's actually utterly, utterly meaningless because you've got, you've, well, as you know, it is, it's not useful energy. What you really need to be counting is how much do we need in the economy and then work back to how we fulfill that. And the thing I've come up with now is saying that measuring energy demand in primary energy is about as useful as measuring nutrition in acres because it's the input to the system. And if we're enormously inefficient and we waste most primary energy, which we do, then it's similar to saying, well, you know, Africa may have vast amounts of acres under cultivation, but it's no good if it…

Helen Czerski

And the clarification here for people who don't think about the physics all the time is that whenever if you get, if you get your energy by combustion, you effectively waste a lot of it as heat. That's why it's inefficient.

Michael Liebreich

Two-thirds of all primary energy is, I mean, it's called waste. Waste is actually not the right word for it. It's also called rejected, because if you want to have, if you want to ride up and down your building in an elevator and you've got a lump of coal, you actually, most of the energy in the…

Helen Czerski

Well, we can have our crusade on understanding Earth as an energy cascade that we can tap into. Helen,

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Everything Electric Podcast