JS John Siracusa John Siracusa Software developer, writer and podcaster who spent 25 years as a full-stack web developer before going independent in 2022.

“How did it know that my mom sent me a WhatsApp message about poison? Is it watching all my messages? And the answer is it has access to all of that. Yes, that's the feature that they're selling you. When it's in a commercial, it's abstract and it's not happening to you and people don't think about it. When it happens to you, it triggers everybody's 'somebody's watching me' thing.”

Accidental Tech Podcast · Tech Strategy & Big Tech · November 2026

“How did it know that my mom sent me a WhatsApp message about poison? Is it watching all my messages? And the answer is it has access to all of that. Yes, that's the feature that they're selling you. When it's in a commercial, it's abstract and it's not happening to you and people don't think about it. When it happens to you, it triggers everybody's 'somebody's watching me' thing.” — John Siracusa, Accidental Tech Podcast

Context

A listener wrote that Siri read out a WhatsApp message and then added a warning about possible poisoning. John explains that the new Siri AI works by reading across your mail and messages, and why people get unsettled when they notice it doing so.

Transcript

Accidental Tech Podcast Around 1:05:15 into the episode
John Siracusa

…to learn about the first one or the second one because I just kept being thwarted by having to like repeat the one that it said and figure out which snippet. And now I would definitely do first one and second one. Unfortunately, on my Gary, I have not found that that stopped it from asking me.

Casey Liss

…if you've been supposed to poison, you should go to the emergency room immediately. Wasn't sure. That wasn't aware Siri did this. Did I miss the memo? Were you guys aware of this functionality? Siri is listening to the semantic meaning of my messages. Yeah, this was news to me. I had no idea. Well,

John Siracusa

this gets back to the thing before about the semantic index. Did you know your Mac is building this dossier on you, learning about who you are? Know and where you go and what your relationships are. Yeah, that's how this feature works. When you say, When does mom's flight arrive? It looks at your email, looks at your messages. Maybe it's a surprise that it can look into WhatsApp messages, but like I feel like anything that does like the app intensor is a messaging application or allows itself to be indexed or participates in spotlight or whatever. That's how this works. And people are freaked out about it because they don't give it much thought. They're like, Yeah, yeah, I saw these demos, or maybe I saw a commercial or something about Siri, this AI, that, whatever, blah, blah, blah. But they, if it until it happens to you, until it's like, how did it know that my mom sent me a WhatsApp message about poison? How did it know that? Is it watching all my messages? And the answer is it has access to all of that. Yes, that's the feature that they're selling you. It, you know, when it's in a commercial, it's abstract and it's not happening to you and people don't think…

Casey Liss

I actually had an interesting experience with this that I didn't even think to bring to the show, but you made me think of it. So when I moved to the duo, I added my main bank accounts, credit card and debit card to Apple Pay. This is the account where basically all of Aaron and Maya's money is.…

John Siracusa

don't think I'd say, I think it's just the Apple security. No, no, no, not AI. You know, basic secure input system that like when this is a secure input text field and when it appears, it's not screen recorded.

Casey Liss

Yeah, yeah, agreed.

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Accidental Tech Podcast