LS Liron Shapira Liron Shapira Host of Doom Debates, the #1 show for high-stakes debate about AI extinction risk.

“I believe in the Icarus curve. So we're Icarus right now and we're going up because we're flying closer and closer to the sun. And that's great. Flying closer to the sun is better, right? You get a better view. It's fun. But eventually your wings burn off and you just plunge into hell and it's game over.”

Doom Debates! · AI Research & Frontier Labs · October 2026

“I believe in the Icarus curve. So we're Icarus right now and we're going up because we're flying closer and closer to the sun. And that's great. Flying closer to the sun is better, right? You get a better view. It's fun. But eventually your wings burn off and you just plunge into hell and it's game over.” — Liron Shapira, Doom Debates!

Context

Shapira was answering the challenge that people who expect AI catastrophe should be betting against the stock market. His reply is that a doomer expects earnings to keep rising for some years and then go to zero. He says that when he plugged in those numbers he got a valuation close to where stocks trade today.

Transcript

Doom Debates! Around 1:05:58 into the episode
Speaker 2

I think that's right. Yes.

Robert Wright

I mean, I can't vouch for it, but it sounds like what I've heard.

Liron Shapira

…right? So that's kind of like the nuclear option. So therefore, from there, you can derive that the value of the stock is the value of its future cash flows. So, you know, it's a good theory. It holds up in many cases over the long term. So you take the U.S. stock market right now and you say, what are the future cash flows if you're an AI doomer like me? Well, I think I've mentioned before that I believe in the Icarus curve. So we're Icarus right now and we're going up because we're flying closer and closer to the sun. And that's great. Flying closer to the sun is better, right? You get a better view. It's fun. But eventually your wings burn off and you just plunge into hell and it's game over. Okay. So that's the cash flows, right? Where it gets like higher and higher than the plunges. So I substituted a number. I'm like, yep, the cash flows are going to grow like 30% per year, but then like in seven years, the AI is going to be uncontrollable and the cash flows are going to go to zero, what they call the terminal value. Like the terminal value is just zero. There's no residual value…

Speaker 2

And did you hear back?

Liron Shapira

So I didn't hear back on that. But then there's another twist to the story, which is my old friend Max Raden from college tweeted back at me and he said, well, what about interest rate? Have you considered the bond market? And I was like, so even though in equities, I feel like Tyler Cowan doesn't…

Robert Wright

Huh. Yeah, the bond market is a little mysterious to me. I mean, a lot of factors, inflation weighs into it. Our treasury secretaries attempt to intimidate it, apparently unsuccessfully, intimidate the bond market. A lot going on. I mean, I do think short term, you could have a you could have a…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Doom Debates!