Machine Learning Street Talk · AI Research & Frontier Labs · August 2026
Becker had been taking apart Ray Kurzweil's extrapolation of Moore's Law into a general law of history. The host had just raised the lily-pad image — a pond covered exponentially until suddenly there is no pond left to cover — and this is Becker's flat version of the objection. He goes on to note that Kurzweil's own curve quietly ignores the early history of computing, where the trend did not hold.
…clearer view of what's been happening in the recent past. And then the more distant past is more distant. And so you can't see it as well. And so you end up with this sort of, you know, logarithmic view of the past that is something that I think Kurzweil is mistaking for a true exponential trend.
…know, things that might have been more globally important to our success. And then he kind of fitted it on a graph. And this isn't just this is a very natural thing, right? The world is complicated. And to make it make sense, we kind of select things that privilege the way we think about the world.
…top of a skyscraper, right? You see the stuff closer to you more clearly, and the stuff that's further away and less directly impacting you is smaller and farther away and harder to see. But yeah, I mean, it's a natural mistake. And also, like many other people, and as you were alluding to with the lily pad example that I was talking about in the book that I pulled from Kurzweil, he forgets that the one thing that you can always say about any exponential trend, the one thing that's always true, is that they end. You know, yeah, he has the lily pad example to give an idea of how exponential growth works. He says, you know, if the lily pads double every day and on day 29, they cover one half of the pond. Well, then on day 30, the pond is full. I'm like, yeah, and then on day 31, the lily pads don't grow anymore because they filled the pond. There's no more pond. And even Gordon Moore himself said, oh…
But I suppose it is a bit of a straw man just to make the sigmoid case. So what they would say is that the actual exponential curve is the stacking of sigmoids. And in technology, whether it's Betamax or whether it's film processing technology, what tends to happen is you get these disruptions. So…
Yeah, yeah, yeah, yeah. No, that's exactly what Kurzweil says. He says, you know, the exponential trend is itself made by a bunch of sigmoid curves and each curve lets you get further up the overall exponential trend. Sure, yes, he does say that. But as I say in the book, there is absolutely no…
Yes, but there does seem to be an obsession with infinity and keeping going. I mean, you gave another wonderful example of Jeff Bezos. And apparently he said he was very, very scared of stasis. So for him, death is the lack of growth, right? Yeah. And there's a wonderful bit in your book, Wait…