HM Hamish McKenzie Hamish McKenzie Co-founder of Substack and its Chief Writing Officer, the role in which he represents writers' interests inside the company.

“The human-to-human connection is something that AI literally cannot replace. Those human relationships will go up in value and become more important. I think of Substack not as a content network but a media relationships network, and those relationships become only more important in a world where robots increasingly mediate our media experiences.”

Sinocism (Bill Bishop) · Geopolitics & World Affairs · November 2026

“The human-to-human connection is something that AI literally cannot replace. Those human relationships will go up in value and become more important. I think of Substack not as a content network but a media relationships network, and those relationships become only more important in a world where robots increasingly mediate our media experiences.” — Hamish McKenzie, Sinocism (Bill Bishop)

Context

The host asked where Substack fits in an AI phase of the internet, with more generated content and slop. This is the start of his answer; he goes on to say AI also has a place in the media economy.

Transcript

Sinocism (Bill Bishop)
Hamish McKenzie

…Now, what are you going to do with them? Like, you send them somewhere where you've got to like can have a solid ongoing relationship with them and that you can benefit from the accruing value rather than just like kiss them on the street and wave goodbye and hope they come back again the next day.

Bill Bishop

…for the people who are starting to use it pretty or integrated pretty well into their lives, AI is clearly changing their relationship with how, with media and with how they consume information. And so where does Substack fit in, say, the AI phase of the internet in terms of media and content?

Hamish McKenzie

Yeah, I mentioned before that is I think of Substack not as a content network, but a media relationships network. And those relationships have always been critical, but become only more important in a world where robots increasingly mediate our life experiences and especially our media experiences. The human-to-human connection thing is something that AI literally cannot replace. And so the human-to-human connection, those human relationships will go up in value and become more important, will become more appreciated. And so being the network of human-to-human connections from Substack's perspective is a very good place to be. And it also helps us give more strength to the human-to-human connection people, the people who are focused on those things. That's not the same thing as saying AI is bad or AI shouldn't have a place in the media economy. AI obviously already does have a place in the media economy. It's just how is it going to be in relation to the human-to-human connection piece? And I think that both are going to be important. I read a lot of stuff that is mediated by robots at the moment and it has a place in my life.…

Bill Bishop

And also, I guess, individual substance, we can write an AI. What do you call it? We're basically talking about how we use AI statement that gets appended to the ethics statement. Yeah, I need to do, I mean, I use AI a lot. I don't use AI to write my newsletter, but I do a lot of translations and…

Hamish McKenzie

ahead. I was just going to say, I think the people who are using it for the lazy shortcuts might not get rewarded by audiences, but the people who use it well to create more thoughtful work should get rewarded by audiences.

Bill Bishop

I think that's right. And to your point, I mean, you'd be crazy not to use AI, especially if, you know, if you're a brilliant, beautiful, creative writer, you're writing wonderful stories, then you don't need AI or doing it. But if you're, you know, my, my newsletter, I'm more, you know, I'm not…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Sinocism (Bill Bishop)