EK Elliot Kaufman On Conversations with Coleman

“Benny Gantz once told me, Netanyahu's a better politician than I am. He meant that as an insult, okay? He's a politician. But when I heard that, I thought there's just one problem. You're in politics. And he is your political opponent.”

Conversations with Coleman · Ideas & Essays · October 2026

“Benny Gantz once told me, Netanyahu's a better politician than I am. He meant that as an insult, okay? He's a politician. But when I heard that, I thought there's just one problem. You're in politics. And he is your political opponent.” — Elliot Kaufman, Conversations with Coleman

Context

Coleman Hughes asks who Benny Gantz is and what part he played in Israel's war cabinet. Kaufman calls him a tragic figure who led the polls for much of the war and has since fallen to almost nothing.

Transcript

Conversations with Coleman Around 1:20:49 into the episode
Elliot Kaufman

And that is the perfect example. Iran was using Hezbollah to make Tel Aviv into Seoul, essentially. And so Israel took that out in September and late 2024. And then October 2024, it takes out crucial Iranian air defenses protecting the nuclear program, leaving that undefended for later on.

Coleman Hughes

Yeah. Tell me who Benny Gantz is and what his role in general was in the Israel’s War cabinet and strategically in Israeli politics.

Elliot Kaufman

…the story of In the War Room:. But the last thing I would say about Gantz, because for much of the war, he was leading all the polls, set to be the next prime minister of Israel, and now he's at next to nothing. He might not even make it into the parliament, the Knesset. His junior partner, Eisencott, has since become the guy, the leading Netanyahu rival. Let me tell you what happened like this. Benny Gantz once told me, Netanyahu's a better politician than I am. He meant that as an insult, okay? He's a politician. But when I heard that, I thought there's just one problem. You're in politics. And he is your political opponent. And I think what happened is that Benny Gantz was right. And Israeli liberals, the Israeli center left, came to believe that as well. That Benny Gantz, though admirable in his character in wanting to do what was right with Israel and just put the country first. And it was never entirely clear what that meant, but they liked that message. At a certain point, they realized you have to beat…

Coleman Hughes

So he's the Ned Stark of Israeli politics, to make a Game of Thrones reference. The leader you wish you had, but who wasn't willing to do what it took to actually unseat those somewhat worse leaders. Talk to me about the role of the far right in the war. And I think it's important context for…

Elliot Kaufman

It is fair, and I think you're right. What they would say, though, is that they didn't boycott Netanyahu for no reason. That he betrayed them in this previous agreement he had with them. And so it's a bit rich for him to then come and say, work with me once again. But in terms of practical…

Coleman Hughes

Okay, so let's zoom out and talk about the core legacy of the October 7th war, including the war against Hezbollah, the war on Iran. There's the whole domino effect of things that have happened since October 7th. And I'm going to ask you the effect of that war on various particular situations. So…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Conversations with Coleman