KH

Kyle Harper

Things Kyle Says on Podcasts

Where to Find Them

Kyle Harper writes The HC Commodities Podcast . They have also been a guest on Sustainability, Climate Change, Renewable Energy, Politics, Activism, Biodiversity, Carbon Footprint, Wildlife, Regenerative Agriculture, Circular Economy, Extinction, Net-Zero · One Planet Podcast (2 times) , Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas , Converging Dialogues , Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning , Dwarkesh Podcast and The David Frum Show .

Recently: “Kyle Harper: a natural and human history of the Holocene” on Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning (November 2026); “#510 - The Last Animal: A Dialogue with Kyle Harper” on Converging Dialogues (October 2026); “371 | Kyle Harper on How Humans Have Shaped Life on Earth” on Sean Carroll's Mindscape: Science, Society, Philosophy, Culture, Arts, and Ideas (October 2026); “The Preventable Return of Deadly Diseases” on The David Frum Show (September 2025); “Why Rome actually fell: plagues, slavery, & ice age — Kyle Harper” on Dwarkesh Podcast (April 2025); “The Fate of Rome: climate, disease and the end of an empire with Kyle Harper” on The HC Commodities Podcast (December 2022).

What They Said

“It's within our technological capacity to drive huge numbers of whales to extinction. There'd be plenty of reason economically why people would benefit from it. And we chose not to do it. It was purely a choice based on values globally to develop the whaling conventions. … There aren't huge numbers of success stories, so it's nice to highlight them where they exist.” — Kyle Harper, Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning

Razib had noted that the whales were saved despite fears for the blue whale and others. Harper uses the whaling conventions as an example of humans collectively choosing not to exploit a profitable resource to extinction.

Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning · 2026-11-18 Permalink → Listen →
Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning Around 1:01:18 into the episode
Razib Khan

…made that now that equilibrium is totally out of kilter because, you know, different organisms like penguins have like increased numbers to feed on, you know, some of the krill or whatever. I don't know. It's like, obviously, it's a big change, but I do want to note that that was successful, right?

Speaker 2

So

Kyle Harper

it's a great, I won't go on about it, but it's a great example of how, you know, we do have the ability to make choices that sometimes do have really dramatic effects. The 20th century was devastating for whales. And we have the technological capacity and we have good economic reasons to kill whales. Like it would be profitable. And so it was purely a choice based on values globally to develop the whaling conventions that saved, that did absolutely, as you say, at the very last minute, in many cases, on the brink of extinction, stopped whales. It's within our technological capacity to drive huge numbers of whales to extinction. Like I say, it'd be plenty of reason economically why people would benefit from it. And we chose not to do it. And it's a good example of a success story. There aren't huge numbers of success stories. So it's nice to highlight them where they exist.

Speaker 2

Okay. So a couple of things before we wrap up. I want to. So a lot of people in the United States do not know that even like three generations ago, chicken, you know, chicken was a little bit on the exotic side, and it was actually more expensive than other types of meat. Today we take for granted…

Kyle Harper

Yeah, the Costco $5 chicken is a miracle of agro-capitalism slash the revenge of the dinosaurs. Because if you were an alien and you visited Earth, you might well say, oh my gosh, there are 35 billion chickens that dominate this planet. And they've trained this bipedal primate to build them houses…

Speaker 2

The age of the chicken.

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“The late Quaternary megafaunal extinction is a terrible name. What a horrible failure of branding, because this is a really dramatic, weird, important moment in the history of evolution. And it doesn't have quite the place it deserves in our imagination.” — Kyle Harper, Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning

Harper was describing how, at the end of the Pleistocene, big land animals disappeared on every continent after humans spread and began hunting. He says the scale of the loss is far larger than the famous mammoths and saber-toothed cats.

Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning · 2026-11-18 Permalink → Listen →
Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning Around 14:09 into the episode
Kyle Harper

…I mean, if the planet were tipped into a totally fundamentally different sort of physical state that was like Venus, yeah, it'd be pretty hard to kill to kill the prokaryotes, but it could happen. I mean, you know, in principle, the Earth could have wobbled into one of these other planetary states.

Razib Khan

…have been arguments traditionally about what caused those extinctions, climate change or us. You take a particular perspective on that, I think, in the book from what I read in it. And can we talk a little bit about that? Because I think it's really interesting just to go over the details here.

Kyle Harper

Yeah, I mean, let's start by zooming out and then kind of zooming in. So the Pleistocene is the geological epoch of the last 2.6 million years down to the beginning of the Holocene, a little under 12,000 years ago. And it's a period of repeated ice ages interrupted by interglacials like our current Holocene when it warms up, but then it cools back down. And the Pleistocene, it's easy for us to forget, but as you know, is sort of the home for human evolution. Most of our evolutionary history takes place against the backdrop of a Pleistocene world. And that's true both in the larger sense of the genus Homo, but also of the species Homo sapiens. And if Homo sapiens have existed for something like 300,000 years, even so, 95% of our history is Pleistocene history. And during that history, we are hunter-gatherers. We rely on taking energy from wild plant and animal sources in the environment. And maybe the most striking evolutionary change in the Pleistocene, if you were like just looking at the fossil record objectively and leave us aside…

Razib Khan

Yeah. So a lot of people do not know. Actually, I mean, a lot of people don't think about the ice age all the time. Okay. I think I do think about the ice age. A fair amount, so I'm a little different than a lot of people, but there was an Emian, there was an earlier interglacial, like 120,000…

Kyle Harper

Yeah. And I mean, I like the mention of the Osage Orange, which is a tree that some listeners may be familiar with. If you've ever noticed a weird tree that has this very strange fruit, it's like the size of a softball. It's got these like weird brain-like looking little grooves all over it. It's…

Razib Khan

Yeah. And this is one of some, you know, these sorts of realities about the ecosystems that emerged, you know, well, during the Pleistocene is one of the reasons that there have been some scholars and activists who want there to be kind of a rewilding of, you know, parts of mostly, you know…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“De-extinction is not a scalable solution to the biodiversity crisis. … I don't think there are realistic scenarios in which mammoths and mastodons become a real part of our biosphere ever again. But heck, that ought to encourage us to protect elephants. … You can bring back a dire wolf, but you can't really give it an ecosystem.” — Kyle Harper, Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning

Razib had just defended de-extinction projects as motivated by missing megafauna rather than mad science. Harper separates de-extinction from rewilding and argues that protecting real ecosystems matters more than reviving single species.

Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning · 2026-11-18 Permalink → Listen →
Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning Around 23:34 into the episode
Kyle Harper

They don't propose it. Just for the lulls,

Razib Khan

…are supposed to be there to be in the ecosystem. And so the ecosystems that we have now across the world, they're quite different. I don't know if you want to say they're not the way they should be because nature is the way it is. Extinction happens and we as humans are here. And, you know,

Kyle Harper

…and still have a real chance to thrive in certain places. And then rewilding can mean lots of different things from planting a natural yard to setting aside national parks and other kinds of reserves, public and private, which I think are by and large a great idea, precisely because they allow ecosystems to survive. And that's actually somewhat in tension with the de-extinction project, because you can bring back a dire wolf, but you can't really give it an ecosystem. Whereas protecting real wild ecosystems where nature can thrive at the system level is actually one of the best things we can do.

Razib Khan

Yeah, this is just a little bit of tangent, but you know, this was one of the, without the lack of the ecosystem, the lack of the world in which a species used to exist, this is actually kind of at the heart of the, I think it was Isaac Asimov story, Ugly Little Boy. And they brought a Neanderthal…

Kyle Harper

Yeah, it's amazing to think about it in those terms. And it will be permanently etched in the fossil record that something happens right at this interval where this new bipedal primate starts to spread that systemically, pervasively, everywhere on Earth across every taxon, life gets smaller. It's…

Razib Khan

Well, you know, okay, I want to talk about domesticates real quick, but I do want to say, to me, like one of the best arguments for like the necessary role of humans is the arrival of humans to Cuba. You know, I think it was 6,000 years ago, Cuba still had groundslaws. And then humans show up and…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.
“The Costco $5 chicken is a miracle of agro-capitalism slash the revenge of the dinosaurs. If you were an alien and you visited Earth, you might well say, oh my gosh, there are 35 billion chickens that dominate this planet, and they've trained this bipedal primate to build them houses and feed them and get rid of their poop.” — Kyle Harper, Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning

Razib Khan asked about the rise of industrial broiler chickens, once a marginal farm animal. Harper argues the chicken is the most successful bird, and arguably dinosaur, in evolutionary history, and that this is a very late and very fast outcome of 20th-century industrial farming.

Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning · 2026-11-18 Permalink → Listen →
Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning Around 1:04:26 into the episode
Kyle Harper

…to drive huge numbers of whales to extinction. Like I say, it'd be plenty of reason economically why people would benefit from it. And we chose not to do it. And it's a good example of a success story. There aren't huge numbers of success stories. So it's nice to highlight them where they exist.

Speaker 2

…chicken as the, you know, it's the one you go to when you're pinching some pennies, right? When things are a little tight. Can you talk about like, you know, the indoor boiler chickens and all, you know, the theropods, the theropod dinosaurs that, you know, are like dominating our world in a way.

Kyle Harper

Yeah, the Costco $5 chicken is a miracle of agro-capitalism slash the revenge of the dinosaurs. Because if you were an alien and you visited Earth, you might well say, oh my gosh, there are 35 billion chickens that dominate this planet. And they've trained this bipedal primate to build them houses and feed them and get rid of their poop. And yeah, then they kill them and fry them up. But the chicken tells the human story in this profound way because it is the most successful bird in the history of evolution. So you can think of it as the most successful dinosaur in a sense. And it's a very weird and unexpected kind of success. And it's a very late one. The chicken is not one of our early domesticates. It's the domesticated version of the red jungle fowl, which is native of Southeast Asia, which enters the human fold probably after the arrival of grain agriculture over the last four or five thousand years. It's not like an early Holocene domesticate. And it spreads late. I mean, it spreads into Western Asia, into Europe, very late. And it's less, you know, it's much less important for most of history than it…

Speaker 2

The age of the chicken.

Razib Khan

All right. So, you know, we've been going for longer than an hour, and I know you got another meeting coming up soon. Dr. Harper, so I want to like close out. Obviously, you know, just scratch the surface. You've been working on this book for a while. lot in there. It's a book. So, you know, just…

Kyle Harper

Yeah, I mean, a little bit. And obviously, I'm a professional historian. And so my expertise is in looking at the past, but I'm also a citizen and wouldn't have written the book if I didn't care about the environment and if I didn't think that this is going to be an important part of our legacy.…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

Collections They Appear In