KH Kyle Harper On Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning

“De-extinction is not a scalable solution to the biodiversity crisis. … I don't think there are realistic scenarios in which mammoths and mastodons become a real part of our biosphere ever again. But heck, that ought to encourage us to protect elephants. … You can bring back a dire wolf, but you can't really give it an ecosystem.”

Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning · Ideas & Essays · November 2026

“De-extinction is not a scalable solution to the biodiversity crisis. … I don't think there are realistic scenarios in which mammoths and mastodons become a real part of our biosphere ever again. But heck, that ought to encourage us to protect elephants. … You can bring back a dire wolf, but you can't really give it an ecosystem.” — Kyle Harper, Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning

Context

Razib had just defended de-extinction projects as motivated by missing megafauna rather than mad science. Harper separates de-extinction from rewilding and argues that protecting real ecosystems matters more than reviving single species.

Transcript

Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning Around 23:34 into the episode
Kyle Harper

They don't propose it. Just for the lulls,

Razib Khan

…are supposed to be there to be in the ecosystem. And so the ecosystems that we have now across the world, they're quite different. I don't know if you want to say they're not the way they should be because nature is the way it is. Extinction happens and we as humans are here. And, you know,

Kyle Harper

…and still have a real chance to thrive in certain places. And then rewilding can mean lots of different things from planting a natural yard to setting aside national parks and other kinds of reserves, public and private, which I think are by and large a great idea, precisely because they allow ecosystems to survive. And that's actually somewhat in tension with the de-extinction project, because you can bring back a dire wolf, but you can't really give it an ecosystem. Whereas protecting real wild ecosystems where nature can thrive at the system level is actually one of the best things we can do.

Razib Khan

Yeah, this is just a little bit of tangent, but you know, this was one of the, without the lack of the ecosystem, the lack of the world in which a species used to exist, this is actually kind of at the heart of the, I think it was Isaac Asimov story, Ugly Little Boy. And they brought a Neanderthal…

Kyle Harper

Yeah, it's amazing to think about it in those terms. And it will be permanently etched in the fossil record that something happens right at this interval where this new bipedal primate starts to spread that systemically, pervasively, everywhere on Earth across every taxon, life gets smaller. It's…

Razib Khan

Well, you know, okay, I want to talk about domesticates real quick, but I do want to say, to me, like one of the best arguments for like the necessary role of humans is the arrival of humans to Cuba. You know, I think it was 6,000 years ago, Cuba still had groundslaws. And then humans show up and…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

More from Razib Khan's Unsupervised Learning