JC

Jonathan Czin

Things Jonathan Says on Podcasts

Where to Find Them

Jonathan Czin has been a guest on The Lawfare Podcast , The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition and The Foreign Affairs Interview .

Recently: “Lawfare Daily: Did Washington Walk Into Beijing’s Trap? Xi’s State Visit with Jonathan Czin” on The Lawfare Podcast (September 2026); “Lawfare Daily: Did Washington Walk Into Beijing’s Trap? Xi’s State Visit with Jonathan Czin” on The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition (September 2026); “Is China Leaving the United States Behind?” on The Foreign Affairs Interview (January 2026).

What They Said

“I have often joked that planning a summit with the Chinese is like wedding planning, but really, it's like wedding planning with the worst possible in-laws you can imagine. Like they don't like the food, they want to haggle over everything. So it requires a tremendous amount of preparation.” — Jonathan Czin, The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition

Czin, a former National Security Council staffer, is explaining why he expected little from Xi's state visit. He says there were almost no in-person preparatory meetings beforehand, so there wasn't the runway that summits with Beijing need.

The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition · 2026-09-30 Permalink → Listen →
The Lawfare Podcast: Patreon Edition Around 07:18 into the episode
Jonathan Czin

I can assure you, I have many squirrel-like moments too.

Julia Curlee

…that. So let's start with your expectations going into this summit. So I watched a bit of what you'd written and spoken about. And, you know, you said you had pretty low expectations, I think, that for an extension of what you call the gentleman's agreement. Could you walk us through that?

Jonathan Czin

Yeah, I mean, it was driven by kind of two main factors, right? I think, especially as a former NSC staff, just at a very mundane level, it was very hard to detect any signs of kind of meaningful discussions since the last summit, right? There were a couple of engagements, but Ho Life Feng and Secretary Besson, who had the lead on these issues, hadn't had any in-person meetings until just the week before the summit. You had the Executive Vice Foreign Minister, Ma Zhao Shu, come in the middle of August for a pretty abbreviated trip. So really, like these trips, I think your listeners should be aware, they just require a painstaking amount of effort, right? And work, and especially with the Chinese, right? I have often joked that, you know, planning a summit with the Chinese is like wedding planning, but really, it's like wedding planning with the worst possible in-laws you can imagine, right? Like they don't like the food, they want to haggle over everything. So it requires a tremendous amount of preparation. And that just didn't go into this, right? So I think just at a…

Julia Curlee

Yeah. So, John, I mean, I want to get a little bit more on this council that was involved in national security of which you speak in the previous administration and help just tee this up just a little bit more on how you would contrast with how this administration, you know, prepared for this…

Jonathan Czin

Yeah, I mean, when I was on the National Security Council, I mean, the preparation that would go into this would start months ahead of time, right? And you're negotiating with the Chinese over every aspect of this: the content, the sequencing, how this is going to go down. And especially since, you…

Julia Curlee

Yeah. So if we were still so fortunate to have you writing the PDB on the summit, how Beijing might perceive the outcome, objectively, how we all did, the scorecard of a summit like this. What would you write in terms of what was agreed with the deliverables, the optics, and anything else? How…

Speaker names come from our own diarization. The position is estimated from where the line sits in the episode.

Collections They Appear In