The Cognitive Revolution" | AI Builders, Researchers, and Live Player Analysis · AI Research & Frontier Labs · November 2026
Nathan proposed trading chip access for Chinese commitments on AI safety. Buchanan describes the Chinese side's opening position in the 2024 Geneva talks and why the Biden team refused to trade chips for talks.
…if you had us in power, you would see very aggressive, aggressive in a good sense, very sort of highly prioritized negotiations with the Chinese, probably in the way that you want. The precise question I have for you is: would you, as a precondition to those negotiations, sell China access to GPUs?
I think I would try to bundle, yeah, chips for controls is kind of my general label for this. That's the
end game. What they're saying on the front end, what they said to us in Geneva on the front end is sell us chips, right? We'll talk about that other stuff later if you want, but start by selling us chips. And I think that's not a posture where I don't want to speak for Teddy, but I'm pretty confident that's not a posture we were willing to take. And that's the policy choice you have to confront with the government: do you want to sell them this technology in the hopes of getting a deal later, knowing that that will shrink the lead? If we could know with certainty that, you know, we'd have a great system of solving these problems and AI safety would be great, then sure, but that's not how international politics works.
Yeah, I mean, I do think attitudes may have changed over there quite a bit. I mean, how do you read the, you know, Xi gave his first big keynote on AI at the WAIC this summer. He talked a lot about forestalling loss of control, the need for international cooperation. Maybe one way to kind of square…
I think that'd be the best news ever if they had that update. We're not in power, so we don't know where they are right now. But I can tell you, if we were in power, you would see us continuing to try to have these negotiations with them. The only point I'm making is I would need to see more than…
There's a simplified version of this that is a matter of binary principle. You do engage or you don't engage. You do work with your competitors or you don't work with your competitors. And I think a big part of what we're trying to say is it's not a binary. There's this whole spectrum of exactly…